The Supreme Court split 4-1-4 in the eagerly awaited environmental case of Rapanos v. United States. On June 19, 2006, Justice Scalia dramatically recited his holding from the bench as though it commanded a majority of the Court. In fact, he could not hold the support of Justice Kennedy, and the entire controversy must return to the Court of Appeals for reconsideration.
Newspapers ran three contradictory headlines to report the result. The headline in the Washington Post was "Supreme Court Reins in Clean Water Act." But readers of the New York Times saw this headline: "Justices Divided on Protections for Wetlands." A suburban California paper, the Tracy Press, was praised by one commentator as having the most accurate headline: "Court Affirms Wetlands Protection."
The Pacific Legal Foundation represented John Rapanos, a 70-year-old grandfather who dumped sand on his own wet land, against the government's 12-year lawsuit to fine and even imprison him for many years. At one point the federal government appealed a lenient sentence of Rapanos in its zeal to impose something harsher. Eventually the trial judge dismissed the criminal case by declaring Rapanos to be "the kind of person that the Constitution was passed to protect."
Yet the government continued to pursue its civil lawsuit against Rapanos. The outcome hinges on how broadly the Army Corps of Engineers can interpret "the waters of the United States" (a phrase in the Clean Water Act) in requiring federal permits for filling wetlands.
Mr. Rapanos's wetlands were some 11 to 20 miles from the nearest navigable waterway. Justice Scalia, joined by Justices Thomas and Alito and Chief Justice Roberts, found it silly for the Army Corps of Engineers to interpret "the waters of the United States" to include virtually every bit of saturation. They observed that the cost of obtaining a federal environmental permit is astronomical. "The average applicant for an individual permit spends 788 days and $271,596 in completing the process," and the Clean Water Act simply does not authorize the federal government to act like a "despot" over every patch of damp soil in the nation.
But Justice Scalia could not persuade Justice Kennedy, who came to the court from the parched state of California. Justice Scalia seemed angry at Justice Kennedy's refusal to join his opinion. Justice Scalia wrote that "Justice Kennedy's disposition … is a … flouting of statutory command" and "is … extreme." Justice Scalia added, "Justice Kennedy … has devised his new statute all on his own." A feud between those two Justices does not bode well for the future.
As the pivotal fifth vote, Justice Kennedy's view effectively becomes the governing law. He was just fine with federal regulation of Rapanos' wetlands provided they "possess a significant nexus with navigable waters."
What sort of "significant nexus" would satisfy Justice Kennedy? He suggested examining "the quantity and regularity of flow in the adjacent tributaries" and "pollutant filtering, flood control, and runoff storage." This is a Pandora's Box that could take years and hundreds of thousands of dollars to resolve in the courts. This murky standard simply pushes landowners towards obtaining a permit rather than rolling the dice in court, particularly with a possible penalty of going to jail. So the practical effect is what Tracy Press headline declared.
Chief Justice Roberts, to his credit, lamented the confusion wrought by the inability of the justices to agree. He laid the blame at the doorstep of the Army Corps of Engineers for overreaching in the first place.
Economist Ronald Coase won a Nobel Prize for observing that a free market can thrive regardless of where the property entitlements are drawn, as long as they are clearly drawn somewhere. But the Court failed to accomplish that simple task of establishing a bright-line limitation on the federal regulation of wetlands.