It was an extraordinarily bold political move: Republican Tom DeLay pushed for a mid-decade redistricting of his state of Texas to replace the court-ordered districting based on the 2000 census. Redistricting is necessary in nearly all states every ten years based on new census data. A second redistricting in between censuses is highly unusual. But when Republicans finally won control of the Texas Statehouse after nearly 150 years of Democratic dominance, DeLay sought a reapportionment that would be fair to Republican congressional candidates.
The results of DeLay's strategy were dramatic: a shift of six seats. The Texas congressional delegation changed from a Democratic majority of 17-15 in 2002 to a Republican majority of 21-11 in 2004.
Democrats were furious. The Democratic state legislators fled to Oklahoma to avoid a quorum and delay passage of this second redistricting. By leaving the state, the Democratic legislators were beyond the jurisdiction of the governor to compel them to attend a special session for this purpose. Eventually a Democratic legislator returned to the state and the Republicans then replaced the unfair system that had favored Democrats with one that favored Republicans.Democrats were furious. The Democratic state legislators fled to Oklahoma to avoid a quorum and delay passage of this second redistricting. By leaving the state, the Democratic legislators were beyond the jurisdiction of the governor to compel them to attend a special session for this purpose. Eventually a Democratic legislator returned to the state and the Republicans then replaced the unfair system that had favored Democrats with one that favored Republicans.
Declaration of Independence signer Elbridge Gerry, who served as a Republican governor of Massachusetts (1810-12) and as Vice President (1812-14), would be amazed at how computers can perfect his concept of drawing district lines to favor a political party. Governor Gerry's political opponents, the Federalists, called his salamander-shaped district a "Gerrymander," and that derogatory name has stuck. Computers have made it easier to carve up a state in a way that crams registered voters of the disfavored political party into a few districts, while creating more districts with safe majorities for the favored party. A state that has an even split in party affiliation can be converted through computerized gerrymandering into a 2-1 majority in congressional representation by a favored party.
But it was the Democrats in Texas who had exploited gerrymandering more than the Republicans. In 2000, there was a 59-40% Republican majority in statewide races, yet the congressional delegation under a court-ordered districting plan was majority Democratic in 2002. When Republicans finally turned the tables and redrew the congressional districts, many Democratic congressmen were then defeated.
The Texas Democrats responded by running to federal court, arguing that the gerrymandering was too political to be constitutional. But the Court held 5-4 in favor of the Texas Republicans, affirming nearly all of its new redistricting. League of United Latin Am. Citizens v. Perry, 2006 U.S. LEXIS 5178 (June 28, 2006). It found the drawing of only one district to be defective, and that was for a reason relating to race rather than politics. Six different opinions were issued by the nine Justices on the Court, illustrating how divided they are on political issues.
The five-Justice majority held that a state can redistrict mid-decade as desired by a new party in charge. The Court declined to place any constitutional limitation on politically motivated gerrymandering. Elbridge Gerry would have been proud.
Justice Kennedy embraced the ruling of the district court that "the Constitution does not prohibit a state legislature from redrawing congressional districts in the middle of a census cycle" and that the Supreme "Court has not yet endorsed clear standards for judging the validity of partisan gerrymanders." Yet the five-Justice majority could not even agree on that, disagreeing among themselves with respect to the breadth of the holding. Justice Alito and Chief Justice Roberts joined Kennedy, while Justices Scalia and Thomas wrote stronger statements against judicial interference with gerrymandering.
Tom DeLay is no longer in Congress, but an important of his legacy has just been vindicated.