Court Monitor • Sep 8, 2006

Court Prohibits Removal of Obscenities

Text Reader

Ever since the Warren Court in the 1960s, federal courts have almost always held in favor of pornography and obscenity in lawsuits. In no other area of law does the same type of business win so repeatedly. Between 1966 and 1970, the Supreme Court issued 34 unsigned decisions in favor of pornography, each of which overturned lower court decisions. This sent a powerful message in favor of obscenity to the lower courts, a message they continue to follow to this day. Chalk up another victory for obscenity in the case of CleanFlicks of Colorado, LLC v. Soderbergh, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 47700 (D. Colo. 2006). Having already won a right to peddle obscenity, movie makers have now won the power to prevent others from removing obscenity from films. CleanFlicks is a family owned business in Utah that removes "sex, nudity, profanity and gory violence" from films to make them suitable for families. CleanFlicks protects the revenue of the filmmaker by buying an extra copy of every edited film it creates, and by requiring the customer to purchase the unedited version of the film for every sanitized version purchased. CleanFlicks even stopped selling to any retailer who makes unauthorized copies of a sanitized version. The Hollywood studios producing obscenity claimed this is a violation of their copyright. But to CleanFlicks and similar companies named as defendants, they have the right under "fair use" doctrine to sell authorized and edited versions of purchased films. CleanFlicks even increased the sales for the Hollywood studios because every sanitized version corresponded to a new sale of an unedited unit. Defendants noted that "Studios benefit because they are selling more copies of their movies as a result of the editing parties' practice of maintaining a one-to-one ratio of the original and edited versions. It is assumed that the consumers of the edited versions would not have themselves purchased the authorized versions because of the objectionable content and the Studios do not compete in this alternative market." The federal district court in Denver rejected CleanFlicks' arguments and ruled in favor of Hollywood. It held that CleanFlicks' argument about increasing sales has "superficial appeal but it ignores the intrinsic value of the right to control the content of the copyrighted work which is the essence of the law of copyright. Whether these films should be edited in a manner that would make them acceptable to more of the public playing them on DVD in a home environment is more than merely a matter of marketing; it is a question of what audience the copyright owner wants to reach." But the Court offered no authority for its view that a copyright owner can control "what audience" he "wants to reach." Besides, presumably the Hollywood studios would like to reach any audience that maximizes their sales. Defendants cited a precedent allowing government libraries to photocopy medical journals, without their consent, for use by researchers. Williams & Wilkins Co. v. United States, 487 F.2d 1345 (Ct. Cl. 1973), aff'd, 420 U.S. 376 (1975). But an argument that is perfectly acceptable elsewhere is a loser in federal court when opposing pornography. The Court concluded by insulting CleanFlicks and the other defendants: "Their business is illegitimate." This lawsuit had been pending since 2002. But the Court gave CleanFlicks and the other defendants only five business days to turn over their entire inventory of sanitized films to the Hollywood studios for destruction, and to swear to an affidavit confirming compliance. In addition, the studios subsequently filed a motion reflecting their intention to demand substantial attorneys' fees. Our federal courts order the removal of the Ten Commandments but prohibit the removal of obscenities. Congress should amend the copyright law to overturn decisions like this one.