The Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit has a reputation for defending free speech. For example, its Judge Frank Easterbrook penned a famous decision invalidating, on the grounds of free speech, a feminist law against pornography. American Booksellers Ass’n v. Hudnut, 771 F.2d 323 (7th Cir. 1985)
Judge Easterbrook recently had another opportunity to defend free speech. But this was speech opposed by the gay rights movement. If it is unconstitutional to ban pornography, then surely it would likewise be unconstitutional to penalize someone for criticizing homosexuality.
But we heard not a peep in defense of a free speech right to criticize homosexuality by the ordinarily bombastic Judge Easterbrook. Instead, he joined an opinion written by Clinton-appointed Judge Diane Wood, which allowed a college to terminate an instructor for handing a student pamphlets critical of homosexuality. Piggee v. Carl Sandburg College, 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 23733 (7th Cir. Sept. 19, 2006)
The two pamphlets, religious in nature, expressed the opinion that homosexuality is sinful. An instructor by the colorful name of Martha Louise Piggee handed the pamphlets to a gay student, who then complained to college officials. The college officials declared that the instructor had somehow sexually harassed the student, and formally admonished her.
Located in Galesburg, Illinois, Carl Sandburg College is a public community college. One expects public colleges to respect a full right to leaflet, collect petition signatures, and engage in free speech on campus. That probably remains true with respect to mocking President Bush or protesting the war, but it is no longer true for criticizing gay conduct.
The college officials found sexual harassment based on contorted reasoning: "It has been found that because of [the student’s] sexual orientation, [the instructor] has been proselytizing in the hopes of changing [the student’s] sexual orientation and religious beliefs." The college officials recommended in their written admonishment that the instructor be warned to cease and desist and, if she did not comply, then she could be terminated.
The instructor apparently complied with the college’s admonishment, but it did not matter. At the next opportunity, the vice president of instructional services advised the director of the instructor’s department that it would be unwise to renew this instructor. She lost her job. Free speech for religious criticism of gay behavior is rapidly diminishing.