The Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit covers Kansas to Utah and Wyoming, and as far south as New Mexico. This Court seemed best situated to end some incentives that motivate illegal aliens to break into the United States unlawfully.
On May 20, 2004, Kansas Democratic Governor Kathleen Sebelius signed into law Kansas House Bill 2145, now codified as K.S.A. § 76-731a. It provides that illegal aliens can obtain preferential, lower in-state tuition rates at Kansas state colleges. This attracted at least six Kansas students who were undocumented, illegal aliens and did not otherwise qualify for the lower in-state tuition. They enjoyed the lower tuition in attending the University of Kansas (KU), Kansas State University (KSU), and Emporia State University (ESU) during in the 2004-05 school year.
Incensed by this, out-of-state American students (who failed to qualify for in-state tuition rates) sued. They claimed that K.S.A. § 76-731a violates federal immigration law and the Equal Protection Clause by discriminating against them and other Americans.
An applicable federal immigration law, 8 U.S.C. § 1623, is captioned "Limitation on eligibility for preferential treatment of aliens not lawfully present on basis of residence for higher education benefits." It mandates that "an alien who is not lawfully present in the United States shall not be eligible on the basis of residence within a State … for any postsecondary education benefit unless a citizen or national of the United States is eligible for such a benefit (in no less an amount, duration, and scope) without regard to whether the citizen or national is such a resident."
That federal law seems clear enough in prohibiting the Kansas law. Under the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution, the Kansas law cannot contradict federal law. But the trial court dismissed all their arguments, and this case went up to the Tenth Circuit on appeal. University of Missouri-Kansas City law professor Kris W. Kobach, the leading legal expert on illegal immigration, argued for the student-plaintiffs.
But Professor Kobach could not persuade the Court even to reach the substance of this case. Although courts allow broad challenges to other statutes, the Tenth Circuit refused to consider the merits of any of these students’ arguments against this Kansas law. Day v. Bond, 2007 U.S. App. LEXIS 20790 (10th Cir. Aug. 30, 2007).
These out-of-state students pay far more in tuition than the illegal aliens pay for the same education, but the Court held that the out-of-state students have no injury. Their tuition would be the same regardless of whether the illegal aliens received the in-state discount, the Court held, and thus these Americans lacked legal standing to sue. As to the federal law, the Court declared that there is "no legal right under § 1623 to assert preemption that was invaded by the implementation of K.S.A. § 76-731a, and the Plaintiffs' claim of such an individual legal right under § 1623 to support standing is legally invalid." Thus this argument by the out-of-state students was also rejected.
So it is back to the books for students objecting to the preferential treatment of illegal aliens. How about judges hitting the books also, and applying the laws against illegal immigration?