It was not long ago that single-sex fraternities and sororities were a central part of the college experience. But the College of Staten Island, a public college in the City University of New York system, now denies recognition to fraternities (or any organization) that discriminate on the basis of gender.
A relatively small fraternity named "Chi Iota Colony," which sought to remain male-only, sued for recognition by the school. The fraternity said that admitting women might lead to romantic relationships between members, causing "inevitable jealousies and other conflicts." The trial court agreed with Chi Iota Colony, and issued an injunction forcing the school to recognize this fraternity. The school appealed.
In Chi Iota Colony of Alpha Epsilon Pi Fraternity v. City Univ. of N.Y., 2007 U.S. App. LEXIS 21891 (2d Cir. N.Y. Sept. 13, 2007), the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled against the fraternity and reversed the trial court. Judge Pierre Leval held that the First Amendment rights of association of the fraternity did not rise to the level of protection of most constitutional rights.
Instead, the Court created a new balancing test. "To determine whether a governmental rule unconstitutionally infringes on an associational freedom, courts balance the strength of the associational interest in resisting governmental interference with the state's justification for the interference." The Court held that this will require an assessment of (1) the strength of the associational interests asserted and their importance to the plaintiff; (2) the degree to which the rule interferes with those interests; (3) the public interests or policies served by the rule imposed; and (4) the tailoring of the rule to effectuate those interests or policies.
In other words, if judges take a dim view of what an association is doing, then governmental interference with its rights of association will be allowed. The "strength of the associational interests" are now being determined by judges, rather than by the Constitution.
Perhaps surprisingly, the Court even placed significance on how the fraternity reached out to the community to attract members. It suggested that if the fraternity functioned secretly in a manner completely hidden from public view, then its associative rights would be stronger. That suggests that the more an association reaches out to a community, the less rights it enjoys under the Constitution.
The Court did not deny the right of the all-male fraternity to exist, but held that the school may continue to refuse to recognize the fraternity. That denies the fraternity the use of campus facilities and services, which is essential for it to attract membership and contributions.
Eliminating single-sex schools and clubs was a fad led by the feminists in the 60s and 70s, but it has become increasingly apparent that males and females often do better in single-sex educational environments. For example, the Pingle School in England found that 12-year-olds were behaving badly in a co-ed environment. The school separated the boys from the girls for most of their lessons and found in a later study that 85% of boys and 82% of girls said they preferred being taught separately. The head of the school described the improvement in behavior as "phenomenal". Yet when a fraternity takes the same approach at a public college in New York, the group is ostracized and accused of discrimination.