Court Monitor • Dec 31, 2007

Federal Court Slaps Arrogant School District

Text Reader

Traditionally public schools have won case after case in court, benefiting from a presumption that they are doing what is best for the community and children. Nearly every lawsuit brought by parents against public schools has resulted in a crushing defeat for the parents. But the Buchanan County school district pushed its luck too far. In Cole v. Buchanan County School Bd., 504 F. Supp. 2d 81 (W.D. Va. 2007), a federal district court in Virginia held a public school board accountable for retaliating against a reporter critical of the school. A reporter for a small-town newspaper wrote a series of highly critical articles. Rather than recognizing the First Amendment right of free speech, however, targets of the criticism passed a surprise resolution at a school board meeting stating "that if the [reporter] entered school property, he would be prosecuted for trespass." A few days later the school board passed a formal resolution stating that the reporter was on "multiple occasions hiding around trees and/or bushes" and that this caused concern by teachers and parents "especially when children are present while school is in session." This resolution, which passed, ordered that the Superintendent shall inform the reporter that: "he shall not enter any school property during operational hours while school is in session and students are present, except upon express written invitation or to attend a public board meeting or to exercise his right to vote. Any violation of this notice may result in prosecution for trespass under Va. Code. §§ 18.2-119 and -128." Perhaps the school board was imitating how a Massachusetts public school did arrest a parent who visited the school to object to the pro-homosexual propaganda being taught to his young child. That school was never held accountable for its mistreatment of a parent, and the Virginia school probably thought it could treat a reporter the same way. The reporter sued for infringement of his constitutional rights, under Section 1983 of Title 42 of the United States Code, for infringing on his right to free speech, due process and equal protection of the law, plus a claim for defamation. Similar constitutional claims have been unsuccessful when brought by parents against schools. The Virginia school board insisted it enjoyed "legislative immunity" from liability for its actions. District Judge James Jones was not impressed by the school. Barely containing his disapproval of its actions, he held against the school board on every one of its major arguments. On the free speech claim, Judge Jones held that: "The First Amendment right of free speech includes not only the affirmative right to speak, but also the right to be free from retaliation by a public official for the exercise of that right." Constantine v. Rectors & Visitors of George Mason Univ., 411 F.3d 474, 499 (4th Cir. 2005) (citing Suarez Corp. Indus. v. McGraw, 202 F.3d 676, 685 (4th Cir. 2000)). To sufficiently plead a First Amendment retaliation claim, a plaintiff must allege that: (1) he engaged in activity protected by the First Amendment; (2) the defendants are government officials who took some action that negatively impacted or chilled the exercise of his First Amendment rights; and (3) there was a causal relationship between the protected activity and the defendants' conduct." Judge Jones ruled against the school board on every ground. He rejected its claim of legislative immunity by finding that the resolution was administrative in the way it focused on only the reporter. Judge Jones allowed the reporter to proceed with his lawsuit on all his constitutional claims. How about courts treating parents with the same respect that Judge Jones gave to this reporter?