Is there a constitutional right for a dying patient to buy an experimental medical treatment? It seems unjust, if not unconstitutional, to deny a terminally ill patient the right to use a promising new therapy. Organizations representing patients with terminal illnesses sued to obtain access to drugs not yet approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
Supporters of such a right for terminally ill patients cite the Declaration of Independence. "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness." These patients are pursuing life, and to many it seems "self-evident" that no government could properly prohibit a patient from buying a drug that might help save his life. The patients sought seeking access only to drugs that had already passed limited safety trials, but were not yet approved for general use.
The trial court disagreed with the patients. It held that it could not find this new right in the Constitution, and dismissed their lawsuit.
On appeal to the D.C. Circuit, the patients took their argument before a three-judge panel appointed by Reagan, Clinton, and the current President Bush. In a 2-1 reversal of the trial court decision, Clinton-appointed Judge Rogers found a new constitutional right to access new treatments. Abigail Alliance for Better Access to Developmental Drugs v. von Eschenbach (D.C. Cir. May 2, 2006).
The FDA, defending its authority to decide which drugs are safe and which are not, urged reconsideration by the court. Judge Rogers responded with a stirring defense of her opinion. She invoked precedents that included the Meyer-Pierce doctrine, which established the right of parents over the education of their children. That right is found nowhere in the text of the Constitution, yet remains essential to conservatives in defending against mandatory enrollment in public schools and interference in homeschooling.
In dissent, Judge Griffith decried the slippery slope of finding a constitutional right to new treatments. He wondered where this new constitutional right might lead. Would a patient next have a constitutional right to marijuana for health purposes? Judge Griffith continued, "Would the majority’s right guarantee access to federally-funded stem cell research and treatment?" Perhaps this barn door of constitutional rights to medical care is best kept closed after all.
Judge Griffith’s view that there is no constitutional right to potentially life-saving drugs may apparently prevail. The entire D.C. Circuit has taken the rare step of ordering that this matter be reheard en banc for reconsideration by all the judges. This suggests that a majority of the judges disapprove of this new constitutional right.