Lynette Petruska was replaced in her job solely because her boss wanted a man instead. Ordinarily that would trigger substantial liability for the employer under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits gender discrimination in the workplace.
The Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit nevertheless affirmed the dismissal of Ms. Petruska’s Title VII claims against Gannon University, a Catholic college located in Erie, PA. Petruska v. Gannon University, 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 22682 (4th Cir. Aug. 16, 2006). The Court found that Ms. Petruska was indeed terminated because she was a woman, but that the college had a constitutional right to do so.
To reach this result, the Court resurrected the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment. This Clause has been moribund ever since the Supreme Court held that it does not require exceptions from generally applicable laws in Employment Div. v. Smith, 494 U.S. 872 (1990). In other words, if a law applies equally to virtually everyone as Title VII does, then the Free Exercise Clause alone would not require a special exception for religious purposes.
But the Third Circuit invoked precedents that predate Employment Div. for the proposition that a religious institution has the constitutional "right to decide matters of faith, doctrine, and church governance." 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 22682, at *19.
Mrs. Petruska was the first female University Chaplain of Gannon University, appointed to replace the Reverend Nicholas Rouch when he departed to study in Rome. Although Bishop Trautman, the Chair of Gannon’s Board of Trustees, apparently approved her appointment, about a year later he began instructing the leadership at the college that Mrs. Petruska could not remain in her position. The Catholic Church, of course, has long adhered to a male-only priesthood.
Yet Mrs. Petruska refused to budge or consider other positions within the college. The provost would not comply with the Bishop’s instructions. For two years Mrs. Petruska remained as University Chaplain despite the Bishop’s order. Ultimately the college implemented a restructuring that required Mrs. Petruska to report to the Reverend Rouch, who had returned from Rome. She refused, and resigned rather than be fired. The college accepted her resignation immediately, and she sued for gender discrimination.
This type of lawsuit against a religious institution is growing in popularity, and has been the subject of recent media coverage sympathetic to the employees. Seven other appellate courts have sided with the religious institutions, holding that there must be a narrowly defined "ministerial exception" to federal anti-discrimination statutes.
The Third Circuit held for the first time in its jurisdiction that, although Title VII plainly prohibits gender discrimination by religious institutions, the Free Exercise Clause prevents applying Title VII to ministerial functions within religious institutions, such as chaplain duties. The Supreme Court has not yet addressed this issue, so this battle is far from over. Note that religious freedom would have lost in this case if the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) had been added to the Constitution.