Court Monitor • Mar 24, 2007

Reinstating Affirmative Action

Text Reader

The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals is split almost evenly between liberals and conservatives, long making it a battleground for judicial appointments. For example, President Bush’s nomination of Henry Saad to this circuit was filibustered for years until he finally had no choice but to withdraw. But a remarkable statistical oddity happened in the biggest case there in years. Instead of drawing a mixture of conservatives and liberals to a three-judge appellate panel, the big case drew a panel containing three of the most conservative judges in the nation. This big case was the challenge to Michigan’s new law banning affirmative action. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action v. Granholm, 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 32235 (6th Cir. Dec. 29, 2006). Passed by a margin of 58% to 42% in November 2006, this state referendum prohibits affirmative action at state schools. Added to the Michigan Constitution as Article 1, Section 26, this new law states that "the University of Michigan, Michigan State University, Wayne State University and any other public college or university, community college, or school district shall not discriminate against, or grant preferential treatment to, any individual or group on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in the operation of public employment, public education, or public contracting." Opposition to this new law was intense and, the day after the election, groups sued to block it. They were then quickly joined by the University of Michigan, Michigan State University and Wayne State University. The Democratic Governor also opposed the law, but she was the defendant in the lawsuit and had no need to intervene. A lawsuit challenging a statute is very dangerous when both sides of the dispute secretly agree because plaintiffs and defendants can stipulate to what they both want the court to do. So they stipulated that "the application of [the referendum] to the current admissions and financial aid policies of the University parties is enjoined through the end of the current admissions and financial aid cycles." That would prevent enforcement of the law to the current school admissions process. The trial judge then entered a temporary injunction enforcing this stipulation. Case closed for this school year? Not so fast. A white applicant to the University of Michigan Law School moved to intervene on December 18. Ignored by the trial judge, he appealed on December 22nd to the Sixth Circuit to overturn this injunction and allow the law to take effective immediately. Had he drawn a typical panel, the appellant would still be waiting for a decision. But by chance he drew three of most conservative judges in the entire nation: Jeffrey Sutton, Alice Batchelder, and Richard Suhrheinrich. Judge Suhrheinrich is famous for previously ruling in favor of a display of the Ten Commandments in ACLU v. Mercer County (2005), declaring that the Constitution does not demand "a wall of separation between church and state." Judge Suhrheinrich decried the ACLU’s "repeated references to the ‘separation of church and state,’" observing that "this extra-constitutional construct has grown tiresome." Judge Batchelder joined that decision. Judge Sutton was not on that case but was filibustered by liberals for years prior to his confirmation, and he is reliably conservative on issues such as affirmative action. Presented with this appeal on the Friday before Christmas, Judge Sutton issued a scholarly decision in favor of the new law in just four business days. Writing for the unanimous panel, he disposed of all of the objections to the new law banning affirmative action. He stayed the lower court’s injunction and allowed the new law to take effect immediately, thereby allowing the white applicant, and all applicants to state schools in Michigan, to have their applications processed immediately without the distortions of affirmative action.