Court Monitor • Mar 4, 2007

Court Upholds Voter ID

Text Reader

The Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, which presides over Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin, has upheld a new law requiring presentation of photo ID in order to vote. Crawford v. Marion County Election Board, 2007 U.S. App. LEXIS 110 (7th Cir. Jan. 4, 2007). Indiana passed this requirement in 2005 to combat voter fraud, and the Democratic Party and other groups immediately challenged its constitutionality. Prior to this law, proof of voter identity in Indiana consisted of signing one’s name and comparing it to a signature on file. This is a common method of verification used in many precincts throughout the nation. The new photo ID law has exceptions for those in nursing homes, and for people who vote by absentee ballot. But the new law requires the vast majority of Indiana voters to show a government-issued identification, just as they must to fly in a commercial airplane or enter government buildings. If a voter forgets to bring his ID, as sometimes also happens at airports, there is a special procedure. The voter may cast a provisional ballot and return within ten days to display his photo ID, if challenged. Indiana justified its new law based on the fact that its registration rolls include an estimated 1.3 million more names than are eligible to vote in the state. The court was stunned by that figure and, while it expressed some skepticism, no one doubted that there are ineligible voters who attempt to vote. Requiring a photo ID is an excellent way to reduce that fraud. Writing for the court, Reagan-appointed Judge Richard Posner readily conceded that requiring photo ID may deter some people from voting, and that this may impact the Democratic Party more than the Republican Party. But he also observed that requiring photo ID would likely reduce voter fraud, which justifies the legislation. Judge Posner compared the difficulty of catching and prosecuting voter fraud to that of catching and prosecuting litterbugs. Both are nearly impossible to track down after the crime is committed. No one would be able to find, catch and prosecute an imposter who showed up at a polling booth amid hundreds of legitimate voters. Judge Posner conceded that even the slightest inconvenience may deter people from bothering to vote at all. Judge Posner noted that federal and state elections are virtually never decided by a margin of merely one vote, and thus the benefits to an individual from voting are "elusive." It does not take much to discourage many people from voting; a mere rainstorm is known to depress voter turnout. Judge Evans dissented. "Let’s not beat around the bush: The Indiana voter photo ID law is a not-too-thinly-veiled attempt to discourage election-day turnout by certain folks believed to skew Democratic," he exclaimed. But none of that should matter in reviewing duly enacted legislation. Judge Posner deferred to the state legislature in establishing the rules for elections, and he cited both the Constitution and Supreme Court precedents for judicial restraint in this field.