In 1932, the Kentucky & West Virginia Coal & Mining Company gave land to a public school on condition that it be used only for "school and educational purposes." If the educational use ever ceased, then the property must automatically revert back to the company.
The public school used the property for educational purposes until 2000, when it decided to consolidate its school system and sell the parcel. The new owner of the coal company then asked for its property back.
However, the Kentucky Perpetuities Act (1960) requires that any owner who placed this type of condition on a grant, known in legalese as a "possibility of reverter," must periodically record his interest with the county clerk or else lose it. KRS § 381.221. No notice was ever given to property owners of this new legal requirement, and the coal company was unaware of it.
The school cited this law in refusing to return the property, even though the school violated the condition of the original grant. Does that seem fair?
According to Judge Karen Caldwell of the Eastern District of Kentucky, the company loses. Black Mountain Energy Corp. v. Bell County Bd. of Educ., 206 U.S. Distr. LEXIS 91786 (E.D. Ky. Dec. 19, 2006). Judge Caldwell said it is up to the legislature, not the courts, to determine what type of notice is appropriate for property owners when a new law impinges on their rights. She said the "Court will defer to that judgment."
Dating back nearly to medieval England, courts have been invalidating old limitations on the sale or use of land in the name of free enterprise. Judge Caldwell emphasized that there is "an important state interest in reducing impairments of the marketability of title." This issue is a rare example of conflict between free enterprise and pure rights of private property.
The company cited the protection in Article I, Section 10 in the U.S. Constitution against impairments by the state of contracts. Didn’t the Kentucky law violate that constitutional protection by impairing the company’s contractual condition on use of the property?
The Court answered No, based on the right of the company to protect its interest by repeatedly recording it with the county clerk. This law was therefore not "a substantial impairment on the obligations of contracts" adequate to trigger constitutional protection.
The Court declared that even if this were a substantial impairment, the "important state interest of alleviating burdens" on the sale of property would justify the Kentucky law. While that sounds good, in fact the company could have sold this property just as easily as the school. Moreover, the company would not have lost its rights under the legal standards developed in the English common law to alleviate burdens on the sale of property, known as the Rule Against Perpetuities.
The result of the Kentucky statute and this decision is that the original intent of the owner was ignored. Instead of "buyer beware" (caveat emptor), is the moral of this story "giver beware"?