A stunning rebuke to judicial supremacy came from the most unlikely of sources: the top court in New York in Campaign for Fiscal Equity, Inc. v State of New York. The loser was a powerful special interest unaccustomed to defeat at the hands of the judiciary: public school teachers’ unions.
The New York City public schools comprise one of the world’s largest monopolies. These schools serve 800,000 daily meals, more than any public institution other than the armed forces.
These schools soak up over $15 billion a year in taxpayer funds, much of it spent on paying over 80,000 teachers. More than $11,000 is spent per student in the system, whether he ever graduates or not. For 13 years a lawsuit has demanded that New York courts pour far more taxpayer money down this hole. Activist lower court rulings in this case have exposed judicial supremacy at its worst.
Inspired partly by this long-running litigation, similar lawsuits have been filed in 45 out of 50 states to seek court-mandated funding increases for public schools. Even the supposedly conservative Texas Supreme Court ordered an increase in school funding that forced a special session of the legislature to impose a massive new tax on small businesses.
New York judges had been all too eager to comply with demands of the New York City teachers’ unions, which expected a court-ordered increase of up to $5.6 billion per year in new state funding.
But the New York Court of Appeals astounded expectations and reversed all lower court rulings in excess of an additional commission-recommended $1.93 billion in aid, as adjusted for inflation. Even better, this top court said the judiciary should stop meddling in the other branches of government.
The court emphasized that "the Judiciary has a duty to defer to the Legislature in matters of policymaking, particularly in a matter so vital as education financing, which has as well a core element of local control. We have neither the authority, nor the ability, nor the will, to micromanage education financing."
Speaking for the court, Judge Eugene F. Pigott, Jr. made clear his distaste for judicial activism. "Devising a state budget is a prerogative of the Legislature and Executive; the Judiciary should not usurp this power."
While this defeat for the teachers unions is rare, perhaps the tide is finally turning in favor of taxpayers. Early last year the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court tossed out a lawsuit demanding more money for public schools there.
The public schools will undoubtedly be with us for the foreseeable future. But the balance of power in dealing with the public schools may be shifting in favor of taxpayers, and the iron grip of the teachers unions over government may be loosening.