As homosexual groups become more aggressive in promoting their agenda in schools through T-shirts and days of silence, some students are fighting back with T-shirts of their own. Last year, in the sprawling city of Naperville outside Chicago, Heidi Zamecnik was sent to the school dean for daring to wear a shirt that said "Be Happy, Not Gay" in response to pro-gay T-shirts worn the previous day.
The Gay, Lesbian, Straight Education Network had promoted an "Day of Silence" at Neuqua Valley High School, and school officials allowed students to wear shirts carrying pro-homosexual messages. But when Zamecnik expressed a different viewpoint with her T-shirt the following day, the dean demanded that she remove the shirt or be sent home for the day.
Her mother then negotiated a compromise with the dean to change the shirt to say "Be Happy, Be Straight." But allegedly the dean did not stick to his agreement, and arranged for a female counselor to cross off everything except "Be Happy."
The Alliance Defense Fund, which handles many cases for students nationwide, sued the school this year on behalf of the Zamecnik family and another student who also sought to wear a "Be Happy, Not Gay" T-shirt. They moved for a preliminary injunction to allow them to wear the shirts. The federal district court denied their motion, but approved the school's consent to allow "Be Happy, Be Straight" T-shirts. Zamecnik v. Indian Prairie School Dist. ADF has appealed the ruling, arguing for the original phrase.
Naperville is not alone in this struggle. In April, four students were suspended at Rio Linda High School in California for wearing pro-heterosexual T-shirts. The students were protesting how the school grants homosexuals rights to express themselves but does not give the same rights to heterosexuals.
Christina Ivantuk, a protesting student, commented how gay advocates were writing "gay pride" in rainbow colors on their bodies. One of the suspended students, Ilya Beknizrov, noted that "There’s a lot of homosexuals out here, and it is kind of disturbing, you know, and we are protesting about it." .The school principal defended the suspensions by claiming students were defying authority.
In another case appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, activist Judge Stephen Reinhardt ruled against a Christian student’s protest of homosexual activism in his school. There the student Tyler Chase Harper wore a T-shirt that said, "BE ASHAMED, OUR SCHOOL EMBRACED WHAT GOD HAS CONDEMNED" handwritten on the front, and "HOMOSEXUALITY IS SHAMEFUL" handwritten on the back.
Even though the Supreme Court established a right of free speech by students in Tinker v. Des Moines Indep. Cmty. Sch. Dist., 393 U.S. 503 (1969), Judge Reinhardt implied that these T-shirts were hate speech and he affirmed the school's ban. Harper v. Poway Unified Sch. Dist., 445 F.3d 1166 (9th Cir. 2006). Christianity, which was the inspiration for these slogans, was censored for allegedly being offensive to other students.
In a blistering dissent, Judge Alex Kozinski observed the absurdity of pretending to advance tolerance with a "demonstrated intolerance for a viewpoint that was not consistent with their own."
In March the U.S. Supreme Court, perhaps concerned about the implications of this ruling, vacated this opinion on procedural grounds but allowed the school to continue to ban the T-shirts. So the student lost this case, but the legal issues are deferred to another day.