Court Monitor • Jul 30, 2007

Court Invalidates Affirmation Action Program

Text Reader

Chief Justice John Roberts, one of President Bush’s two justices on the U.S. Supreme Court, invalidated a type of race-based school admission policy. . .Parents Involved in Cmty. Schs. v. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1, 2007 U.S. LEXIS 8670 (2007). His opinion did not end all uses of race in school admissions, but did stop the odious practice of public schools choosing applicants based primarily on race. Seattle School District No. 1, which operates 10 regular public high schools, allowed incoming 9th graders to rank their preferences of schools in the district. Some high schools were far more popular than others, and Seattle would admit students to the popular high schools in a way designed to meet racial quotas. When a white applicant was rejected based on race, his family sued. Jefferson County, Kentucky, was also using race as a basis for admitting or transferring students to popular elementary schools. Once subject to a desegregation decree, this school district used race-based admissions long after the decree had expired. Over a half century after Brown v. Board of Education outlawed segregation in public schools, this use of racial quotas may surprise some. Judging applicants by the color of their skin is what liberals criticized for decades. Yet the four liberal Justices on the U.S. Supreme Court defended these race-based admissions policies in Seattle and Kentucky, and invoked the heritage of Brown v. Board of Education for support. Their arguments fell flat when Chief Justice Roberts retrieved and quoted the actual briefs filed in that famous case. "The Fourteenth Amendment prevents states from according differential treatment to American children on the basis of their color or race," declared the brief of plaintiffs in the first Brown v. Board of Education case. Chief Justice Roberts rhetorically asked, "What do the racial classifications at issue here do, if not accord differential treatment on the basis of race?" The Chief Justice quoted counsel Robert L. Carter for the Brown plaintiffs saying, "We have one fundamental contention which we will seek to develop in the course of this argument, and that contention is that no State has any authority under the equal-protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to use race as a factor in affording educational opportunities among its citizens." Chief Justice Roberts observed, "There is no ambiguity in that statement." With Chief Justice Roberts’ leadership, the Court invalidated the race-based admissions policies of the Seattle and Kentucky schools. Race can no longer be used as a primary criterion in admission at government schools. He distinguished prior decisions allowing the use of race by noting that the Seattle school district considered only three factors for admissions: placement of siblings, distance from schools, and race. Such emphasis on race, above all merit or background-based criteria, was unconstitutional under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which prohibits race-based classifications unless there is extraordinary justification. In dissent, Justice Stevens said, "It is my firm conviction that no Member of the Court that I joined in 1975 would have agreed with today’s decision." But Justice Stevens is likely wrong at least about the late Chief Justice Rehnquist, who served in 1975 and was long an opponent of racial quotas.