The Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the Bush Administration’s funding of faith-based programs in a stunning 5-4 victory for conservatives. Hein v. Freedom from Religion Found., Inc., 2007 U.S. LEXIS 8512 (2007). The impact of President Bush’s two appointments to the High Court, Sam Alito and John Roberts, is beginning to be felt.
Justice Alito wrote this opinion, reversing a decision by Judge Richard Posner of the Seventh Circuit. Judge Posner, a libertarian, had opened the door to invalidation of Bush’s funding of religious groups administering community programs.
Faith-based programs were first proposed in 2001, and now $2.1 billion a year flows to religious groups to provide community services such as teaching children, training released prisoners and rehabilitating drug addicts. This is about 11% of the $19.7 billion awarded to all community groups by the federal government. Religion cannot be part of the federally supported programs, but groups receiving the money are religious and some of these groups say grace before eating a federally funded meal.
"Government can't fund preaching or proselytizing, but it can fund the good social work being done by religious organizations," observed Jim Towey, who serves as the director of the Office of Faith-Based and Community Initiatives.
Atheistic groups have been hopping mad about this program for years, and several lawsuits have attempted to stop it. The Freedom from Religion Foundation, Inc., which describes itself as the largest group of atheists and agnostics in North America, sued to stop Bush’s faith-based program. The group based its legal standing on the mere fact that some of its members pay federal taxes. Such "taxpayer standing" has been used in the past to allow almost anyone to invoke the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment to interfere with a governmental accommodation of religion.
The district court dismissed this lawsuit, finding the legal standing to be insufficient. After all, this group was not directly harmed by these programs, which is ordinarily the requirement for legal standing in a lawsuit. Merely paying federal taxes should not entitle anyone to sue under the Establishment Clause to challenge any program.
But Judge Posner reversed the trial court, and ruled in a 2-1 decision that this group does have legal standing to block the Bush Administration. The entire Seventh Circuit, by a 7-4 margin, affirmed his ruling in denying a motion for reconsideration. Dissenting Judge Ripple observed that this issue "can only be resolved by the Supreme Court." Judges Manion, Kanne and Sykes also voted to reconsider Judge Posner’s decision.
And resolve it the Supreme Court did. It dismissed this case and narrowed taxpayer standing to block future lawsuits like it. Justice Alito held for the Court that future challenges under the Establishment Clause will be allowed only if brought against a specific congressional expenditure, rather than an expenditure of discretionary funds by the Executive Branch. Justices Scalia and Thomas would have gone further and also eliminated taxpayer standing for challenges to congressional expenditures.
Justice Souter, speaking for the four liberal justices, howled in dissent. He complained that the majority "opinion closes the door on these taxpayers because the Executive Branch, and not the Legislative Branch, caused their injury."
But there was no real injury; there was simply an attempt to censor religion. The Supreme Court has finally stood up to that censorship.