Court Monitor • Aug 23, 2007

Court Rejects Pay Discrimination Claim

Text Reader

This lawsuit was every company’s nightmare. Lilly Ledbetter worked for Goodyear for nearly twenty years at its Gadsden, Alabama plant. About a year before her retirement, she filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) alleging pay discrimination based on gender. Over the years Ledbetter had received poor evaluations from several supervisors, resulting in lower pay than her male counterparts. Ledbetter complained that her poor evaluations were due to sex discrimination. She sued for back pay extending over her 20-year career. Goodyear said there had been no discrimination, but the jury predictably found against the big company. Goodyear also argued that the applicable statute, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, limits claims to actions occurring within 180 days of the complaint. In other words, Goodyear sought to enforce Title VII's 180-day statute of limitations. The trial court rejected Goodyear’s arguments and the jury awarded Ledbetter an astounding $3.5 million in damages, which included $223,776 in backpay, $4,662 in mental anguish and an astronomical $3,285,979 in punitive damages. Goodyear appealed. The Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit held in favor of Goodyear, overturning the jury verdict. The appellate court held that only the most recent pay decisions could be considered, not numerous decisions made throughout an employee’s career. The court found no evidence of discrimination in those recent decisions about raises for Ledbetter. To resolve a conflict among appellate courts on this issue, the U.S. Supreme Court took this case. Ledbetter’s counsel had every reason to expect success before the High Court, and she had the media on her side. But her appeal proved to be a miscalculation that would slam the door not just on her claim for extended backpay, but similar claims nationwide. The newest Justice, Sam Alito, wrote a 5-4 decision upholding the 180-day limitation of Title VII and denying demands for backpay that extend years into the past. Ledbetter v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., 2007 U.S. LEXIS 6295 (May 29, 2007). This opinion may become the first salvo of an "Alito Court" that repudiates past judicial activism. Alito adhered to the text of the statute in enforcing the relatively short statute of limitations: "We apply the statute as written, and this means that any unlawful employment practice, including those involving compensation, must be presented to the EEOC within the period prescribed by statute." This 180-day period still gives an employee many months to complain about a decision denying a pay raise, and the Equal Pay Act of 1963 provides additional remedies. But the Court, led by Justice Alito, ended the employer nightmare of an employee reaching back 20 years to demand more money. While the media portray Justice Kennedy as the swing vote on the Court, this case illustrates how Justice Alito’s replacement of the left-leaning Justice Sandra Day O’Connor made the difference, not just in the outcome but in the strength of the opinion. Justice Alito was joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, and also by Justices Scalia, Kennedy and Thomas. Business Week reported that this decision is "a death knell to many compensation lawsuits" (June 18, 2007, p. 40). The four Justices in dissent mustered a plea for Congress to overrule the decision by statute, but even that suggestion is a sign of progress, urging use of the legislature rather than the courts to legislate.