For years, teachers union bosses have spent teachers’ fees on liberal political causes with which many teachers disagree. Fed up with this racket, Washington State voters passed Initiative 134 to require labor unions to obtain permission from government employees who are not members of the union, especially teachers, before spending their money on political activity.
When the Washington Education Association (WEA) complied with this law by making these political dues voluntary, the contributions dropped by 85%. That proved what critics had been saying for years: most teachers do not support the political agenda of union bosses.
But rather than accept this fact, the WEA looked for ways to circumvent the new law. The Evergreen Freedom Foundation courageously sued the WEA to enforce the law, and State Attorney General Christine Gregoire filed suit. A trial court found that the WEA had violated the law, and slapped a $590,375 penalty on the union.
Case closed? No, the WEA appealed that penalty and also appealed a separate class action brought by a group of teachers, led by Gary Davenport, against the WEA. The WEA found sympathy with the Washington Supreme Court, which ruled that the union bosses had a constitutional right to require payment of these political dues as part of their freedom of speech and association. The U.S. Supreme Court agreed to review this decision.
In Davenport v. Wash. Educ. Ass’n, 127 S. Ct. 2372 (2007), the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously held against the WEA and rejected its attempt to collect union dues from non-members for political (almost entirely Democratic) use, without their affirmative consent. Justice Antonin Scalia, writing on behalf of the Court, overruled the Washington Supreme Court and held that there is no free speech right and no freedom of association right to compel a worker to pay dues for political purposes.
The U.S. Supreme Court did uphold a Washington State law requiring employees who declined to join the union to pay union dues for collective bargaining efforts. But the Court held that none of those dues may be spent on political activities unless such use is "affirmatively authorized by the individual."
Newspapers nationwide applauded this ruling. But as the Investors Business Daily asked rhetorically, "Now the question is, will the unions obey the ruling?" ("Workers Get To Say No To Labor Bosses," Investor’s Business Daily A18 (June 18, 2007). http://www.investors.com.) Litigation to compel the Washington teachers union to comply with the law has raged for years, and it faces substantial fines now.
This important decision allows states to begin protecting teachers and other workers from mandatory union dues spent on political purposes. Unfortunately, the Democratic governor of Washington – the same Christine Gregoire who initially sued to stop the WEA’s practices – dampened the effect of this ruling by signing into law authorization for unions to attribute political spending to unrelated income from sources other than workers’ dues. As long as a union can cite some other income that might cover the political expenses, this new law enables the union to continue spending the dues on political purposes as before.
While the media portray Justice Kennedy as the swing vote on the Court, this case illustrates how Justice Alito’s replacement of the left-leaning Justice Sandra Day O’Connor made the difference, not just in the outcome but in the strength of the opinion. Justice Alito was joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, and also by Justices Scalia, Kennedy and Thomas. Business Week reported that this decision is "a death knell to many compensation lawsuits" (June 18, 2007, p. 40). The four Justices in dissent mustered a plea for Congress to overrule the decision by statute, but even that suggestion is a sign of progress, urging use of the legislature rather than the courts to legislate.
Nevertheless, an important precedent for workers’ rights has been established. The State of Washington and other states can now strengthen the rights of workers against union politics that do not represent their political views.