The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, known to be the most liberal in the nation, stunned politicians by affirming a tough Arizona law that cracks down against illegal aliens. The tide is turning against the rampant illegal entry that has plagued many states.
The Legal Arizona Workers Act authorizes courts to suspend or revoke the business licenses of any employer who knowingly hires illegal immigrants. Employers who engage in such practices are unfair to competitors who obey the law, and encourage the influx of more illegal aliens into the United States. Such employers also bring unlawful conduct to the community without paying any of the damages caused by increased crime. Arizonans had enough, and in 2007 passed a law to curtail the unlawful activity.
The Legal Arizona Workers Act authorizes any person to submit a complaint to the Arizona Attorney General or to a county attorney identifying the hiring of illegal aliens. The appropriate county attorney must review the complaint and, if legitimate, bring an action against the employer in state court.
The Act also requires participation by employers in E-Verify, an easy-to-use system to confirm the legal status of a worker, although there is no penalty in the Act for failure to do so. In further protection of employers, the Act establishes that employers who act in good faith cannot be penalized.
Penalties under the Act are as follows. A first violation of the rule against hiring illegal aliens results in requiring the employer to fire all illegal aliens, and to file quarterly reports for all new hires for a probationary period. The employer must also file an affidavit stating that it is in compliance. If the employer violates the Act again during its probationary period, then it permanently loses its business license.
Less than one month after enactment of the Act, a lawsuit challenging it was brought in federal court against 15 county attorneys, the state Attorney General, Arizona Governor Janet Napolitano, and other officials. Interest groups insisted that Arizona does not have power to enact its own laws against illegal aliens, and that only Congress has this power (which, of course, it fails to use properly). Furthermore, these groups insisted that the Legal Arizona Workers Act did not provide adequate "due process" to those who would be accused of violating it.
This lawsuit was dismissed by the district court, but then worked its way to the Ninth Circuit, which has historically been so favorable to claims of illegal aliens that the United States Department of Justice has avoided appealing cases to it. Plaintiffs had every reason to expect a victory, and an invalidation of the Arizona law.
But times are indeed a-changing. The Ninth Circuit unanimously rejected this legal challenge and ruled that Arizona may begin enforcing its new law. Chicanos Por La Causa, Inc. v. Napolitano, 2008 U.S. App. LEXIS 19723 (9th C ir. Sept. 17, 2008).
The Ninth Circuit noted that the Arizona law had not yet been enforced; this lawsuit was merely a "facial challenge" to the constitutionality of the law. The three judges on the appellate court unanimously agreed that the Arizona law is constitutional as it was written and enacted. Western states within the jurisdiction of the Ninth Circuit may now protect themselves against the influx of illegal aliens.