Court Monitor • Oct 25, 2008

Florida Court Blocks Vouchers Again

Text Reader

School vouchers enable students trapped in failing public schools to escape and learn elsewhere. For two decades many observers of the declining public schools have supported vouchers as a way to introduce competition and accountability to education. For two decades, teachers unions and school boards have feared and opposed vouchers because they threaten the monopoly they enjoy at public expense. Former Florida Governor Jeb Bush made vouchers a priority in his two-term administration. But he found resistance at every turn, and the resistance continues long after Jeb has moved on. Enacted in 1999, Florida implemented the first statewide private school voucher program. But in January 2006, the notoriously liberal Florida Supreme Court struck down this voucher program as somehow being unconstitutional. The Florida Legislature found two ways around this ruling: it established a corporate tuition tax credit program that functions similar to a voucher program, and it created a voucher program for children with disabilities. These two programs help about 37,000 students obtain a better education than they would otherwise. The cost is perhaps $200 million, less than $6000 per student and cheaper than the average cost of a public school student. The corporate tuition tax credit part of the voucher program has about 19,000 students at a capped cost of only $88 million a year. The independent Florida Taxation and Budget Reform Commission, which meets only once every 20 years, proposed two amendments in 2008 for voters to consider on Election Day. Amendment 7 would have guaranteed religious freedom by allowing tax dollars to go to religious schools. Amendment 9 would have required that 65% of school expenditures be spent on classroom instruction, and it would have ended the constitutional requirement that state-funded education be provided exclusively through "a system of free public schools." These amendments were expected to pass and would have opened the door again to vouchers. The trial court rejected a legal challenge asserting that the amendments went beyond the power of the Commission that proposed them. On appeal, a higher court certified the matter for the direct consideration by the Florida Supreme Court. But every Justice on the Florida Supreme Court voted to censor these amendments from the ballot. Ford v. Browning, 33 Fla. L. Weekly S 641, 2008 Fla. LEXIS 1619 (Sept. 15, 2008). "The Secretary of State and all persons and entities acting under his direction are hereby enjoined from placing proposed Amendments 7 and 9 on the November 2008 general election ballot." The Court even ordered that no motion for rehearing would be allowed. One Justice, in concurrence, stressed how Amendment 9 would have the effect of allowing school vouchers in Florida contrary to a prior decision of the Florida Supreme Court. Accordingly, Floridians are again deprived of full competition in education, but no one expects this to be the last word. Two past critics of vouchers have joined the Florida School Choice Fund, which raises money for Florida’s corporate tax credit voucher program and then awards vouchers to low-income children. The government monopoly over education, and all the harm it causes, will not last forever.