Court Monitor • Nov 14, 2008

Court Upholds Ban on Christmas Music

Text Reader

Year by year, the hostility of public schools to religion continues to worsen. In 2005 a school district in New Jersey prohibited a high school coach from merely bending his knee while his football players initiated a prayer before a game; in 2006 a school in Colorado withheld the diploma from a valedictorian after praising Jesus in her commencement speech, until she apologized. Both victims of this religious hostility lost when they sued in court. The combination of liberal teachers unions and judicial hostility to religion in public life has driven God and morality out of public schools. Increasingly, atheistic teachers are even excluding religion beyond what a court may require. The latest example is even more extreme. A public school district in New Jersey banned the performance of Christmas music at a Christmas concert, even if initiated by student musicians. Two students and their father sued. The school district moved to dismiss the lawsuit by claiming that the ban was not as bad as the students claimed. The school district attached an artfully written official school policy to its motion to dismiss, and relied on that. The policy preached tolerance to all, but implicitly banned Christmas music at Christmas concerts. The court, citing the reasonable-sounding policy, ruled in favor of the school and dismissed the lawsuit. Attorneys for the family, retained by the Alliance Defense Fund, appealed this decision, explaining that the real ban on religious music by the school was worse in practice than the carefully written official policy. The family argued that their lawsuit sought to overturn the real ban in practice, not a written policy that did not clearly acknowledge what was happening. The family drew Judge Jane Roth among the three-judge appellate panel, who was originally appointed by President Reagan and was the wife of the late Republican Senator from Delaware, William Roth. She wrote an opinion in favor of the students, and overturned the trial judge. Speaking for the Third Circuit, Judge Roth ordered the case to be reexamined by the trial court to review the school’s real ban. Stratechuk v. Bd. of Educ., 200 Fed. Appx. 91 (3d Cir. 2006). Accordingly, this case went back to the trial court, but it stuck to its prior decision and again ruled in favor of the school. Using the malleable Lemon Test, the court denied there was an anti-religious purpose to the ban on an exclusion of Christmas music from Christmas school concerts. The court upheld a teacher’s directive that future music at the Christmas concert use tunes like "Winter Wonderland" and "Frosty The Snowman." "Music centered on Peace is also a nice touch," the teacher had written, and the court concurred. Stratechuk v. Bd. of Educ., 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 66383 (D.N.J. Aug. 29, 2008).