A 4-3 decision of the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts mandated same-sex marriage, which began there on May 17, 2004. Soon same-sex relationships were being taught to children as young as kindergarteners. In January 2005, Jacob Parker was given in kindergarten a picture book, Who's in a Family?, which included depictions of two-dad and two-mom families. "Who's in a family?", the book asked, "The people who love you the most!"
The indoctrination has increased ever since. In March 2006, second-grader Joseph Robert Wirthlin Jr. ("Joey") was subjected to a story of a prince who had been ordered by his mother to get married. The prince first rejects several princesses, only to fall in love with another prince. The book depicted a wedding scene between the two princes, and the last page shows the two princes kissing with a red heart superimposed over their mouths.
The Parker and Wirthlin families asked their schools to give them advance notice before subjecting their very young children to such teachings, which violate their religious beliefs. The schools refused. The Parkers and Wirthlins sued, and the trial court ruled against them.
The case went on appeal to the First Circuit. The families noted that the public schools are systematically indoctrinating the Parkers’ and the Wirthlins’ young children contrary to the parents’ religious beliefs, and in denigration of their "sincere and deeply-held faith."
The families were ably represented by courageous attorneys on appeal, who probably risked retaliation by homosexual activists for taking the case. But against them was a huge array of amicus curiae briefs filed by a top corporate law firm on behalf of the ACLU Foundation of Massachusetts, the American Civil Liberties Union, the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts, the Lexington Community Action for Responsible Education and Safety, the Lexington Education Association, the Massachusetts Teachers Association, and another group called "Respecting Differences."
That's not all. The top law firm in Boston, Ropes & Gray, filed an amicus brief against the families on behalf of the Anti-Defamation League. Filing yet more briefs against the families were the Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, the Gay, Lesbian & Straight Education Network, the Greater Boston Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays, the Human Rights Campaign, the Human Rights Campaign Foundation, and the Massachusetts Women's Bar Association.
The three-judge panel of the First Circuit ruled unanimously against the families. It first cited as authority the Massachusetts’ decision mandating same-sex marriage, and then noted that Massachusetts allows parents to opt out of courses only if they concern sex education. The court found that these teachings were not governed by that law.
The Court declared that it is "well recognized" that "while parents can choose between public and private schools, they do not have a constitutional right to ‘direct how a public school teaches their child.’" Parker v. Hurley, 514 F.3d 87, 102 (1st Cir. 2008) (quoting Blau v. Fort Thomas Pub. Sch. Dist., 401 F.3d 381, 395 (6th Cir. 2005)).
The Court then went further. It held that "there is no viable claim of ‘indoctrination’ here" because "the plaintiffs' children were not forced to read the books on pain of suspension" and "[t]here is no allegation here of a formalized curriculum requiring students to read many books affirming gay marriage." Id. at 106 (emphasis added). The Court declared that even if there WERE [was] compulsion "on pain of suspension" to read "many books affirming gay marriage," the Court still might not find that any indoctrination existed. Id.
The families appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. On Oct. 6, 2008, the Supreme Court refused without comment to hear the case. 2008 U.S. LEXIS 6692. The First Circuit decision against parents' rights in public schools now stands as the law.