Allegations of domestic violence are rampant in family court. Many courts grant virtually every request for a restraining order that is presented to them, no matter how flimsy or unproven the allegations. In divorce disputes over money, an allegation of domestic violence can give one partner the upper hand.
Rarely is anyone punished for making a false allegation of domestic violence, so there is little risk of harm to anyone who fabricates or exaggerates a claim. As an added incentive for domestic violence allegations, free legal assistance is provided to the accuser but not to the accused.
The New Jersey couple of Crespo and Crespo divorced back in 2001. They continued to live on separate floors of a house; Ms. Crespo resided on the first floor with the children and Mr. Crespo lived on the second flood with his parents. They shared custody of the children.
On March 16, 2004, the Crespos had a confrontation. Their accounts of what happened differ widely. Mr. Crespo described Ms. Crespo attacking him while he sat in his car, causing him to respond by closing the car window in self-defense. Ms. Crespo alleges, to the contrary, that Mr. Crespo smacked her in the face after she asked for child support money, and that he also bruised her by pulling on her arms.
Ms. Crespo filed a complaint seeking a Temporary Restraining Order against Mr. Crespo. In addition to her above allegations, she added numerous other claims of domestic violence dating back 15 years that were never filed with the police. Without hearing the other side, the Court granted a Temporary Restraining Order against Mr. Crespo banning him from his own home, prohibiting him from communicating with Ms. Crespo, denying him his right to own a gun, and depriving him of any parenting time or visitation with the children.
Then, on April 20, 2004, the court issued a "Final Restraining Order" against Mr. Crespo. It made the temporary order permanent, including a prohibition on Mr. Crespo returning to his own home.
For four years Mr. Crespo attempted to obtain a ruling overturning these onerous restraints, citing a lack of evidence of abuse and ineffective assistance of counsel. All his efforts failed.
In late 2007, however, a new attorney and a new strategy came to Mr. Crespo’s aid. Attorney David Heleniak filed a motion to vacate the Final Restraining Order on the ground that the New Jersey Prevention of Domestic Violence Act (DVA) is unconstitutional. Oral argument was held on March 28, 2008, and Judge Francis B. Schultz rendered a scholarly decision on June 18th. Crespo v. Crespo, Docket #FV-09-2682-04 (N.J. Sup. Ct. Hudson Co. June 18, 2008).
Judge Schultz ruled in favor of Mr. Crespo, declaring the DVA to be unconstitutional on multiple grounds. He held that it violated separation of powers because the legislature imposed procedures on the judicial system that conflict with the courts’ own procedures. Most importantly, Judge Schultz also found a constitutional violation in the standard of proof used in these cases. Domestic violence is considered "proven" by a mere "preponderance of the evidence." If something is 51% likely to have happened and 49% likely not to have happened, then the "preponderance of the evidence" standard is satisfied. It is the easiest burden of proof to meet in court proceedings.
Judge Schultz found that such serious charges, entailing such onerous punishments, should be considered proven only if they meet a higher standard. "That a fundamental right could be forfeited as a result of a rapidly calendared, ‘mere preponderance standard’ clearly offends the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment." Judge Schultz held that "a clear and convincing standard [should] be utilized in domestic violence matters." He remanded the case, however, for further consideration of the proper standard to be applied.
The New Jersey Attorney General has appealed this ruling to try to reinstate the lower standard as a matter of law. The New Jersey Appellate Division will likely rule next year.