For decades courts have been censoring anything and everything religious in schools and government, but how do they react to a lawsuit objecting to a government statement that distorts religion?
The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit considered a challenge to the following taxpayer-funded statement on a government website: "Misconception: ‘Evolution and religion are incompatible.’"
"Response: ‘Religion and science (evolution) are very different things. In science (as in science class), only natural causes are used to explain natural phenomena, while religion deals with beliefs that are beyond the natural world. The misconception that one has to choose between science and religion is divisive. Most Christian and Jewish groups have no conflict with the theory of evolution or other scientific findings. In fact, many religious people, including theologians, feel that a deeper understanding of nature actually enriches their faith. Moreover, in the scientific community, there are thousands of scientists who are devoutly religious and also accept evolution.’"
This governmental statement misleads readers and students into thinking there is no conflict between the theory of evolution and religion, when obvious conflicts do exist. The inverse correlation between belief in evolution and religious faith is undeniable, and scientifically observable. Leading evolutionists, like Richard Dawkins, are typically outspoken atheists; leading clerics, like the late Jerry Falwell, are typically outspoken critics of the theory of evolution.
The conflicts run deep. Jesus talked about the Flood before redeeming the Original Sin of Adam as the father of all humans. Evangelical and Catholic churches prohibit teaching anything contrary to the existence of one, and only one, father of mankind. See,e.g., Humani Generis (1950), Most Americans are churchgoers, and most Americans reject evolution in increasing percentages over time. See, e.g., Science 2006, vol. 313, p. 765 (2006).
A taxpayer filed suit to remove the above-quoted statement, citing the same arguments that atheists have used to censor religion in government. The taxpayer argued that she "is offended by the government's endorsement of religions and religious denominations when she visits the site; that people such as she who believe that their religious belief is incompatible with evolutionary theory are made to feel like outsiders by the State of California and the United States; and that she has been exposed to the government-endorsed religious messages to her harm because UC has opened the site to the general public." Caldwell v. Caldwell, 2008 U.S. App.=2 0LEXIS 20935 (9th Cir. Oct. 3, 2008).
Courts often use these arguments to censor references to God. So what happened when these arguments were presented against a liberal statement about religion?
A unanimous panel of the Ninth Circuit held that the taxpayer lacked standing to object to the website statement, and the court dismissed the lawsuit. "Caldwell's offense is no more than an ‘abstract objection’ to how the University's website presents the subject," the Court held, and that is not enough basis for the Court to order removal of the statement. Yet when a statement suggests alternatives to evolution, as one did in the Dover School District in Pennsylvania, a federal court ordered censorship. Kitzmiller vs. Dover Area School District, 400 F. Supp. 2d 707 (M.D. Pa. 2005).