Extremely violent video games are the obsession of a significant portion of our youth. Studies have shown that "violent video games may be more harmful than violent television and movies because they are interactive, very engrossing and require the player to identify with the aggressor."
http://www.apa.org/releases/videogames.html
To combat this rising problem, in May 2006 Minnesota Governor Tim Pawlenty signed into law its Restricted Video Games Act. This Act sought to prevent minors under the age of 17 from renting or purchasing extremely violent video games, and it subjected violators to a small fine of not more than $25.
Entertainment Software Association, a seller of video games, sued under the First Amendment. A federal district court struck down the law, declaring that excessively violent video games are protected free speech, even for minors. Minnesota appealed.
A three-judge appellate panel for the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously held that extremely violent video games are entitled to as much protection as the Bible. Entm’t Software Ass’n v. Swanson, 2008 U.S. App. LEXIS 5634 (8th Cir. Mar. 17, 2008).
The court relied on and quoted Interactive Digital Software Ass’n v. St. Louis County, in which another panel of the Eighth Circuit likewise held that violent video games are free speech because they contain "stories, imagery, age-old themes of literature, and messages, even an ideology, just as books and movies do." But so do some adult pornographic movies, and no one insists there is a free speech right to sell them to children. Moreover, visual images have a far more powerful effect on immature viewers – even on mature viewers – than the written word.
Violent video games encourage role playing, making the child the perpetrator of the violence in a manner that no book or movie can. It does not require a leap in imagination to see the risk of immature players repeating that violent role-playing in real life.
For example, one of the video games before the Court was Postal 2: Apocalypse Weekend, which boasts it will enable the user "to hack your enemies to meaty bits!" But rather than recognize the authority of government to keep this from children, the Court compared that video game to a violent passage in the Bible. Judge Wollman, writing for the Court, observed that "great literature includes many themes and descriptions of violence. See, e.g., Judges 4:21 (NIV) (‘But Jael, Heber's wife, picked up a tent peg and a hammer and went quietly to [Sisera] while he lay fast asleep, exhausted. She drove the peg through his temple into the ground and he died.’)." What Judge Wollman failed to add is that a literary description of violence in the Bible is not comparable to the gratuitous and graphic gore of video games like Postal 2: Apocalypse Weekend, and no description of violence in the Bible would lead a teenager to imitate it.
Legitimate free speech expresses violence in a rational context, rather than displaying it graphically to evoke an immediate emotional reaction. It is not a First Amendment right to cause panic on an airplane by shouting that someone has a bomb; nor is it legitimate free speech to evoke dreadful reactions in children through graphic video games. A teenager who learns to murder and mutilate human beings in video games is desensitized to commit heinous crimes. The First Amendment should not prevent regulations to stop it.