A massive 43-feet-high cross stands atop Mount Soledad in Southern California, visible for miles around. Located near San Diego, this cross has been the subject of nearly 20 years of litigation by atheists attempting to force its removal. The ACLU has funded this attempt to censor this powerful symbol from public property.
The late Philip Paulson, an avowed atheist, brought one of the lawsuits. He referred to his adversaries as "cross savers" and attributed his atheistic beliefs to an exercise during a sociology of religion class that he took at the ultra-liberal University of Wisconsin. Mr. Paulson died of liver cancer at the age of 59, but his lawsuit survived him with the support of the ACLU.
On July 29th, a stunning federal court decision ruled against the ACLU and in favor of the cross. Trunk v. City of San Diego, No. 06cv1597 (S.D. Cal.). U.S. District Judge Larry Burns held that the cross has become known as a memorial to veterans, and thus can remain based on this secular nature as opposed to its religious meaning. "The Court finds the memorial at Mt. Soledad, including its Latin cross, communicates the primarily non-religious messages of military service, death, and sacrifice," Judge Burns explained.
The Court relied heavily on the precedent Van Orden v. Perry, 545 U.S. 677 (2005), when Clinton-appointed Justice Stephen Breyer sided with the conservatives and provided the pivotal fifth vote to uphold the placement of a monument to the Ten Commandments outside the Capitol in Austin, Texas. Since that decision Justice Sam Alito has replaced Justice Sandra Day O’Connor, who was often hostile to religion in public life, bringing a commanding 6-3 margin of support for that decision on the High Court.
The nonprofit Mount Soledad Memorial Association constructed and continues to maintain the cross, which sits atop public land. The Association has long maintained that the memorial honors veterans, not a religion, and its spokesman immediately applauded the ruling. "That makes me feel terrific because that truly is what it's all about, honoring veterans," Mount Soledad Memorial Association president William Kellogg declared. "Our mission has been to communicate that to the public for so many years, so I think the language there is very appropriate."
The legal maneuvering that led to this victory was far from simple, however. The cross was once on land owned by the City of San Diego, and another federal judge (Gordon Thompson) ordered the City to take down the cross or face daily sanctions. His ruling was based on his interpretation of the California Constitution rather than the U.S. Constitution, insisting that the cross violated a provision in the California Constitution prohibiting preference for religion by state or local government.
Then the defenders of the cross wisely sought and obtained a transfer of the land, on which the cross sits, to the federal government. The federal government need only comply with the U.S. Constitution, not the California Constitution. Accordingly, Congress enacted an extraordinary seizure of the property under eminent domain in order to save the cross.
The ACLU insists that the cross violates the U.S. Constitution also, specifically the Establishment Clause in the First Amendment which states that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion …." The ACLU often pretends that there must be a "wall of separation of church and state," even though no such words exist in the U.S. Constitution and, indeed, Benjamin Franklin suggested that a daily prayer be said to inspire and guide the drafting of that document.
Undoubtedly the ACLU will appeal to the Ninth Circuit, a court known to be unreceptive to religion. That appellate court once invalidated the words "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance, though its ruling was overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court on a technicality. But for now and perhaps forever, the cross will remain atop Mount Soledad. The ACLU has failed in its latest attempt to persuade activist courts to censor religion.