Court Monitor • Aug 22, 2008

Court Reinstates Pledge Requirement in Florida

Text Reader

Two years ago, a federal court in Florida invalidated a state law requiring all students to say the Pledge of Allegiance unless they have express parental consent for refusing to say it. Frazier v. Alexandre, 434 F. Supp. 2d 1350 (S.D. Fla. 2006). Cameron Frazier was a Florida student in the eleventh grade at Boynton Beach Community High School, Palm Beach County, who had refused to stand and recite the pledge each morning since the sixth grade. He refused even after his math teacher Cynthia Alexandre informed Frazier that "Florida state statutes say you may choose not to say the pledge ONLY by written request by your parent AND you still must stand!" When Frazier sued (through his mother), the district court first stated that there is a fundamental right of parents to direct the education of their children: "The right of parents and guardians to direct the education of their children is similarly well-recognized." But despite that admission, the court eviscerated that right by holding that "this right does not translate into a requirement that a parent must give prior approval of a child’s exercise of First Amendment rights in a school setting." The court thereby tossed out the pledge requirement in the statute. On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit unanimously reversed that ruling and reinstated the statute with respect to deferring to parents and requiring their consent before a student can refuse to recite the pledge. Frazier v. Winn, 2008 U.S. App. LEXIS 15546 (11th Cir. July 23, 2008). It upheld the constitutionality of requiring students to obtain written permission from their parents in order to refuse to recite the Pledge of Allegiance. "We see the statute before us now as largely a parental-rights statute," the Court emphasized. It explained that no one can be forced to recite the Pledge of Allegiance, as established by the Supreme Court in the famous case of West Virginia State Bd. of Educ. v. Barnette, 319 U.S. 624 (1 943), but held that the Florida statute does not require anyone to say the pledge and merely requires parental consent not to say it. "Most important, the [Florida] statute ultimately leaves it to the parent whether a schoolchild will pledge or not," the Eleventh Circuit declared. It did agree with the student Frazier, and the State of Florida conceded, that a student need not stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. But he must recite it if his parents want him to, or if his parents do not provide a written request that he be excused from the requirement. The Court held that "unlike in Barnette and in the cases cited by Plaintiff, the refusal of students to participate in the Pledge -- unless their parents consent -- hinders their parents’ fundamental right to control their children's upbringing." The Court found that the "rights of students and the rights of parents -- two different sets of persons whose opinions can often clash -- are the subject of a legislative balance in the statute before us." The Court then opened the way for state legislatures to strike a "balance" in favor of parental rights, even when the powerful First Amendment right of free speech is at stake. "The State, in restricting the student's freedom of speech, advances the protection of the constitutional rights of parents: an interest which the State may lawfully protect," the Court concluded in upholding the statute.