Court Monitor • Sep 18, 2008

Court Overturns Fine for CBS Super Bowl Stunt

Text Reader

During the 2004 Super Bowl, the most-watched television show of the year, CBS broadcast nudity by Janet Jackson during half-time. In what became euphemistically known as a "wardrobe malfunction," Jackson exposed her breast to a surprised audience of millions. 542,000-plus complaints poured into the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), which is authorized to regulate television and radio networks. It fined CBS, the network that hired Jackson and aired the stunt. The fine of $550,000 was far less than the revenue CBS received from just one advertisement during the Super Bowl and only $27,500 for each member station. Congress, hearing the complaints, then passed legislation raising the maximum fine for future offenses to $325,000 per station. CBS did not agree to pay this modest fine, and instead sued to avoid it entirely. The Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit held in favor of CBS and erased the fine in a 99-page decision. The Court let CBS off on two technicalities: first, the FCC had not previously punished broadcasters for fleeting obscene words or images, and second, Jackson was merely a contractor of CBS, not an employee. The Court held that prior legal precedents, especially Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n v. State Farm, 463 US 29 (1983), require that a regulatory agency can only change its policies if it first clearly states in writing its reasons for changing. It held that the FCC changed its policy on "fleeting" obscenity when it tried to punish CBS without first announcing that it would do so. The Court further declared that CBS could not be held responsible for what Jackson did as a contractor, because she was not an actual employee. This conclusion defies the common law and common sense principle that holds entities responsible if their agents misbehave in the course of their duties and nothing is done to stop them. It did not help that the FCC has been so permissive to MTV and other purveyors of sex in the past. The FCC acted in this case because so many complained, but lacked a history of consistent fines against others when not so many complained. The activist Court protected CBS from any penalty, which will have the effect of encouraging all broadcasters to continually push the limits of taste and morals without fear of retribution. Chalk up another victory for the media, and another loss for our culture. Judge Robert Bork once observed that "courts are enacting the agenda of the cultural left." The era of legitimate entertainment has been replaced, thanks to the courts, with a culture of vulgarity and obscenity.