Court Monitor • Sep 7, 2008

Stunning Victory for Second Amendment

Text Reader

The Supreme Court’s June 26 ruling in favor of the fundamental right of self-defense and the Second Amendment was a thrilling victory for America. Justice Scalia, in perhaps his finest opinion, delivered a 5-4 decision invalidating the District of Columbia’s sweeping ban on handguns in District of Columbia v. Heller. The beneficial repercussions of this decision will extend far beyond the District of Columbia, as similar bans in cities such as Chicago and San Francisco may now be unconstitutional. Dick Heller, a D.C. policeman, was refused permission by the District of Columbia to apply for a handgun to keep in his home. Heller sued the District on the ground that this was unconstitutional. His suit challenged the longstanding D.C. ban on unlicensed firearms in the home and its trigger-lock requirement, which effectively destroys the defensive potential of guns. The Supreme Court rejected the position of perhaps 100 judges who have denied that the Second Amendment protects an individual right. Justice Scalia’s decision in favor of the Second Amendment was a triumph for his constitutional doctrine of "textualism", which relies on the actual text and original understanding of a document and rejects both legislative history and the liberal notion of "evolving" law that changes in meaning over time. Specifically, the Supreme Court held that: The Second Amendment allows an individual to possess a firearm regardless of his relationship to the military, and he may use that firearm for lawful purposes, such as self-defense. The Second Amendment’s prefatory clause, "A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State…" does not limit the second part, "…the right of the People to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed." The trigger-lock requirement in D.C. is unconstitutional. The D.C. ban on possession on handguns in the home is unconstitutional. President George W. Bush was quick to praise the Court’s decision. "As a longstanding advocate of the rights of gun owners in America," Bush said, "I applaud the Supreme Court’s historic decision today confirming what has always been clear in the Constitution: the Second Amendment protects an individual right to keep and bear firearms." Republican presidential candidate John McCain went further, declaring that the Supreme Court’s decision was "a landmark victory for Second Amendment freedom in the United States." McCain noted that it "ended forever the specious argument that the Second Amendment did not confer an individual right to keep and bear arms." The Court’s decision, however, did not address the constitutionality of other gun regulations. Justice Scalia wrote, "Nothing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms." The District of Columbia is currently attempting to impose licensing procedures on gun owners. The Heller decision was the Supreme Court’s first substantive interpretation of the Second Amendment in nearly 70 years. But it has been even longer since the Court ruled in favor of the Second Amendment, since the 1939 case United States v. Miller upheld Miller’s federal prosecution for transporting a sawed-off shotgun. Thanks to Justice Scalia’s decision, no one will be able to deny that the Second Amendment guarantees Americans the right to defend themselves with firearms. Self-defense, one of the most basic rights of all, is alive and well due to the Founding Fathers and five Justices on the Supreme Court.