Court Monitor • Oct 10, 2010

Court Approves Pro-Life Initiative

Text Reader

Ballot Measure 2, the Alaska Parental Involvement Act, was an initiative (now law) amending the Parental Consent Act (PCA) by requiring parental consent before a minor under the age of 18 has an abortion, and penalizing physicians who violate this rule. Alaskan law previously required only notification of a parent, not consent by a parent. The new law also prohibits anyone from having an abortion in the state unless they have lived there for the previous 30 days, which curtaila the practice of girls being transported across state lines to circumvent pro-life laws. The last pro-life initiative in Alaska failed by nearly 20 points in the general election in 1982. But because turnout tends to be more conservative in primary elections in Republican states such as Alaska, this time the chances of success were higher. Also, the public is more pro-life now than it was 20 years ago, and typically pro-abortion newspapers have less influence today. Moreover, this initiative did not pull down pro-life Republicans against pro-abortion Democrats because it was on the primary rather than general election ballot. Promoters of abortion fought hard to keep this parental consent initiative off the ballot. Though supporters of the initiative collected several thousand more signatures than the requisite 32,743, they faced a lawsuit in which the lieutenant general was accused of misleading the signers of the petition. Seeing that the petition for the initiative was rapidly gathering support, Planned Parenthood of Alaska and ACLU of Alaska sued by claiming that the summary of the measure misled those who signed the petition, and that the signature gathering process be restarted. The trial court ruled that some minor mistakes did not justify forcing the sponsors to recirculate the petition, and that the summary could be revised before being placed on the ballot. The case was appealed to the Alaskan Supreme Court. The Alaska Family Council then publicized how Sarah Palin-appointed Justice Morgan Christen had been a board member of Planned Parenthood in the mid 1990s, creating a conflict of interest. Amid a campaign by the Alaska Family Council objecting to her presiding in this case, Justice Christen recused herself from it and did not participate. Oral argument was held on May 20th, and subsequently a nearly unanimous decision was reached: the decision of the lower court was affirmed and this initiative be on the primary ballot on August 24th. Perhaps surprisingly, the Anchorage Daily News praised the decision to put this measure on the ballot. Alaska voters easily passed ballot Measure 2. According to LifeNews.com, 70,503 Alaskans voted yes, while 56,354 voted against the measure. It was a victory for parental notification by a 55.5 to 44.4 percent margin.