Court Monitor • Nov 21, 2010

The Biggest Case of 2010: Obamacare

Text Reader

Signed into law in March, after Congressman Bart Stupak and other faux pro-life Democrats caved in and voted for it, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) was immediately challenged by several lawsuits. Virginia brought its own action in federal court, and 20 other states joined a lawsuit filed in federal court in Pensacola, Florida. Both of these cases test whether Congress has the power under the Constitution to compel Americans to buy a product (health insurance) they may not want. Section 1501 of Obamacare requires all Americans to buy a government-approved health insurance plan or else pay a penalty, which the government is now describing as a tax. Federal Judge Henry Hudson, in the Virginia case, denied the government's motion to dismiss, holding that Virginia does have legal standing to challenge Obamacare and the arguments should receive a full hearing. Virginia points out that failing to buy insurance cannot be considered economic activity subject to regulation by Congress under the Commerce Clause. The Commerce Clause has never been interpreted so broadly as to include non-activity. Virginia also explains that Section 1501 exceeds the authority under the General Welfare and Necessary and Proper Clauses of the United States Constitution, and directly conflicts with Virginia Code Section 38.2-3430.1:1 (2010), also known as the Virginia Health Care Freedom Act. This law of Virginia was enacted to preserve the right of Virginians not to be compelled to buy government-approved health insurance. Virginia further argues that Section 1501 violates the 10th Amendment by contradicting the above-mentioned Virginia Health Care Freedom Act, because this Amendment reserves to the States and the people powers not expressly conferred on the federal government. Opponents of Obamacare – a majority of Americans – cheered this decision. But two months later, a Clinton-appointed judge in a similar case brought in Detroit rendered a nearly opposite verdict, holding that the individual mandate requirement is constitutional because otherwise "there would be an incentive for some individuals to wait to purchase health insurance until they needed care, knowing that insurance would be available at all times." Judge George Caram Steeh thereby implied that because the goal of Obamacare is constitutional – reforming the health insurance market that affects interstate commerce – a necessary means to that end must also be constitutional. Critics were quick to point out that the end should not justify the means. It will be years before the various court challenges to Obamacare are finally resolved, but already one aspect is striking: not since the Civil War have so many States asserted their rights as above the power of the federal government. Obamacare has divided Americans rather than unite us.