Court Monitor • Nov 28, 2010

The Vanishing Supreme Court Caseload

Text Reader

The U.S. Supreme Court decided only 72 cases after oral argument in its annual term ending in June 2010, and as of October 7th had accepted for review only 51 cases for its 2010-2011 term. This is far fewer than than the 200 to 300 cases heard annually at the turn of the 20th century, and the roughly 150 cases heard each year in the early 1980s. Only a handful of the 72 cases concern issues of large significance. Most involve obscure or highly technical issues, such as narrow business-related disputes or picayune matters of criminal procedure. Under Supreme Court rules, it requires the agreement of four Justices to "grant cert." and accept a case for review. That rule has not changed for decades, yet the Court's caseload has fallen precipitously. Why? The sharp decline from 150 to about 75 cases per year occurred under the leadership of conservative Chief Justice William Rehnquist in the early 1990s. A supporter of limited government, Chief Justice Rehnquist felt that the U.S. Supreme Court should likewise limit itself. Known to have one of the sharpest legal minds ever to serve on the Court, Rehnquist felt it was better to address a few issues well than try to do too much. Among his clerks was John Roberts, now Chief Justice, who apparently shares this philosophy for judicial restraint. Other conservative Justices, most notably Sam Alito, seem to support widening the net to correct judicial activism by others. The Supeme Court is more conservative than most of the appellate and trial courts. When the Court declines to take a case, it often leaves intact a liberal decision below. Two decisions from the last term are illustrative. In Christian Legal Society v. Martinez, the Court spent weeks trying to decide whether to grant cert. to review a liberal Ninth Circuit decision denying a school club the right to exclude from its membership opponents of its mission. There were four strong votes for reversing the policy, but the fifth vote to reverse the decision below was elusive. The Court ultimately granted cert. but could only render a mixed decision of unclear value. Justice Alito wrote a powerful dissent on behalf of four Justices, which lacks the authority of a Court majority but can still be cited in future cases concerning freedom of association. In another case, whether videos that display shocking mistreatment of animals are protected as First Amendment free speech, Justice Alito was the lone dissent in favor of overturning the lower court decision and upholding the law. United States v. Stevens. Four Justices must have initially agreed to hear the case, but then only Justice Alito wrote in support of reversal. Paraphrasing the famous expression about love, is it better "to be heard and lost, then never to be heard at all?" If fewer than four Justices on the Supreme Court think so, then we can expect the vanishing caseload for the politically divided Supreme Court to continue for the foreseeable future and the majority of judicial influence will rest with lower federal courts.