When a federal district court struck down the City of Hazleton ordinances against illegal aliens in 2007, no one expected it would take three years to obtain an appellate ruling. But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit spent nearly two years drafting its opinion after oral argument, and then rendered a sweeping 188-page opinion against the Hazleton ordinances. Lozano v. City of Hazleton, 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 18835 (3d Cir. Sept. 9, 2010).
Hazleton is a small northeastern Pennsylvania town having only about 23,000 people until it became a magnet for immigrants, lawful and unlawful, who ballooned its population by over 50% in just a few years. This burdened its social services, strained its police force, and was associated with some shocking crimes. The Hazleton City Council, inspired by its charismatic mayor Lou Barletta, passed an ordinance denying business permits to companies that hire illegal aliens, and penalizing landlords who rent to illegal aliens. But before these became effective, a group that included actual illegal aliens sued, and a trial court permanently enjoined the ordinances. An appeal followed.
The appellate decision ruled against the Hazleton ordinances in every way possible, and even declared that unnamed illegal aliens have standing to raise similar legal challenges in the future. The court opinion would not use the term "illegal alien" and instead went with the politically correct "aliens not lawfully present" or "aliens lacking lawful immigration status." This decision, if affirmed or followed by other jurisdictions (the Third Circuit covers only Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Delaware), casts doubt on whether any municipality can protect itself against an invasion of illegal aliens in the future.
The employer ordinance at issue simply required businesses to confirm that they were not employing illegal aliens, with a very mild penalty of a temporary license suspension if they violate the ordinance. The license must be reinstated when the employer fires the illegal alien, and the ordinance included safeguards to protect against firing legal immigrants by mistake. A private cause of action enabled a company to sue for damages caused by a competitor's use of illegal aliens, and a complaint process allowed residents of the town to alert authorities to the employment of illegal aliens. The housing ordinance authorized the City to suspend a landlord's rental license and prohibit him from collecting rent from an illegal alien, but the sanctions end once the owner submits an affidavit confirming that he has corrected his violation of renting to an illegal alien.
The unanimous three-judge panel of the Third Circuit invalidated all this. It held that under the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 preempts Hazleton's employment ordinance because it stands "as an obstacle to the accomplishment and execution" of the goals of that federal law. The Court also struck down the housing ordinance on preemption grounds, emphasizing that the federal government has exclusive authority to regulate immigration and even if Congress did nothing to stem the influx, states and local governments could not pass laws of their own on housing issues.
The Court was critical of nearly everyone who enacted or defended these ordinances, even passing judgment on what it said was the unacceptable intent behind the laws. It is unlikely that this decision will be the final word on this increasingly contentious topic, as many more cases are percolating through the court system.