Court Monitor • Dec 27, 2010

Letter Reveals Liberal Strategy for Supreme Court

Text Reader

Over the years, Republican nominations to the U.S. Supreme Court have ranged from cronyism (like Harriet Miers), to happenstance (like Sandra Day O’Connor), to regrettable mistakes (like William Brennan). Many of the best picks resulted from pure luck (like William Rehnquist). Liberals do not leave such an important selection to chance; they carefully analyze which potential nominee would have the most liberal influence on another sitting Justice. The remarkable disclosure of a personal letter from Professor Laurence Tribe, a leading leftist at Harvard Law School, reveals their behind-the-scenes strategy. http://www.eppc.org/docLib/20101028_tribeletter.pdf Written by Tribe to President Obama in May 2009 shortly after Justice David Souter had announced his retirement, this letter lays out the liberal game plan. Tribe and Obama have known each other since Obama’s law school days, when Tribe credited Obama for supposedly helping him with a legal article that implausibly applied the Theory of Relativity to justify legalized abortion. In the first paragraph of his letter to Obama, Tribe lamented how the last two Democratic nominations did not have "much of a purchase on Tony Kennedy’s mind." This was an insulting reference to Justice Anthony Kennedy, who has occasionally switched over to the liberal side in certain cases. Tribe wanted a nominee who could bring Kennedy more fully to the political left. Tribe did not feel that Sonia Sotomayor, whom Obama wanted for shoring up his standing with Hispanic voters, would be able to persuade Kennedy. Tribe next insulted Sotomayor’s intellect in order to get someone else picked. "Bluntly put, she’s not nearly as smart as she seems to think she is," Tribe arrogantly declared about Sotomayor. Such harsh criticism might seem odd from someone who has himself has been criticized for plagiarism. Sotomayor, in contrast, had an unblemished record of original work as a jurist on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Obama rejected Tribe’s advice and did nominate Sotomayor to replace Souter. Liberals often try to put down moderates and conservatives on an intellectual basis, so Tribe’s style is a familiar tactic. Liberals praise the intellects of others depending on how liberal they are; Obama has been praised as somehow being an intellectual prodigy. Tribe’s letter showed foresight, too, in discussing how to fill a second future vacancy. Tribe anticipated the retirement of Justice John Paul Stevens and made suggestions for filling that seat, too. Whom did Tribe recommend most of all? Elena Kagan, the former Dean of Harvard Law School who had helped close the matter against Tribe for plagiarism. http://authorskeptics.blogspot.com/2005/04/tribe-transgression-dean-velvels-april.html. Tribe extolled Kagan’s prowess at length, despite her never having been a judge, and she was ultimately nominated by Obama to fill Stevens’ seat in 2010.