Underpublicized by the media, a "climate change" analysis is now required prior to the initiation of projects by the National Forest System, an agency of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. The Deputy Chief for the National Forest System promulgated a guidance document that requires the Service to incorporate climate change analysis into its evaluations of project proposals, and this guidance has now been cited approvingly by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Hapner v. Tidwell, 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 19238 (9th Cir. Sept. 15, 2010). The Ninth Circuit has jurisdiction over vast amounts of federal property out West.
This new guidance requires that the "Environmental Assessment" (EA) for a forest clearing project of underburning merely 30,000 acres of ponderosa pine must now include a discussion of the "climate change" supposedly caused by the project. Only if a forestry project is particularly small, such as thinning a forest on only a few hundred acres, may the analysis be omitted.
Note the emphasis in terminology on "climate change" rather than "global warming." This may reflect the discrediting of claims that the Earth has been rapidly warming. Rather than let go of the liberal attempt to control, limit and ration energy, environmentalists and socialists insist that the real problem is "climate change." Of course, the climate is always changing, so no one can deny that "climate change" is occurring.
The climate may warm by half a degree one year, and cool by half a degree the following year, with no overall significant impact. Such fluctuation would be climate change. It would be virtually impossible to disprove whether man-made energy use is causing climate change, so litigation over this issue can spread like wildfire. Under this new government requirement, a project cannot begin until its impact on climate change is somehow assessed and evaluated. Project proposals for governmental action must already include an EA, and that EA must include (speculative) statements about the project's potential impact on climate change.
The Court did allow the particularly small forestry project in Hapner v. Tidwell to move forward for two reasons. First, the court held that the "Project involves a relatively small amount of land and it will thin rather than clear cut trees." Second, the court held that "the Service addressed comments regarding climate change in its December 2007 notice of final decision."
Despite holding against demands by environmentalists to delay this project, the Court still paid homage to the global warming mantra. The Court wrote, "Plaintiffs point out that global warming has been recognized by courts as an issue of national importance. See Massachusetts v. EPA, 549 U.S. 497, 521 (2007); Ctr. for Biological Diversity v. Nat'l Highway Traffic Safety Admin., 538 F.3d 1172, 1221-24 (9th Cir. 2008)."
As of October 7, there have been 163 state and federal court decisions citing "global warming," making it difficult to eradicate this liberal theory even though it is politically motivated and scientifically flawed. But at least courts are ruling against some demands by environmentalists to impede projects based on this theory.