Court Monitor • Sep 25, 2010

Focus Shifts to Lower Courts

Text Reader

"Gridlock" is a term customarily applied to Congress, particularly when government control is divided between Democrats and Republicans. But gridlock at the U.S. Supreme Court, which is divided between liberal and conservative voting blocs, is causing power to shift to lower courts. As an example of the gridlock at the Supreme Court, a fairly routine patent dispute took it an extraordinary seven months to resolve before adjourning on June 28. A case about the extension of the Second Amendment to the States likewise took the Court many months to finalize, and consumed 214 pages. The few other cases on the Supreme Court's docket resulted in fractured and contentious decisions that left many questions unanswered due to a lack of agreement among the Justices. Gridlock is even more apparent in the upcoming term that begins in October. The Court has granted 39 petitions for certiorari – roughly half its annual workload – but only 3 of them have real political significance: whether violent video games are free speech, whether a liberal group has standing to challenge a tax credit system for sending students to private schools in Arizona, and whether an old Arizona immigration law is unconstitutional (that law has already been overtaken by Arizona's 2010 immigration law). That's it. In contrast, many decisions of tremendous importance are being rendered by lower courts, ranging from immigration to global warming to marriage to abortion to health care. Even if these decisions are ultimately accepted for review by the U.S. Supreme Court – which is a big "if" – those final appeals may come too late to make a difference. Our nation is being remade by court order, as conservatives have long complained, but now most often by appellate and trial courts rather than by U.S. Supreme Court. Sometimes government officials do not even appeal decisions rendered by trial courts on issues of great importance to the entire nation. It has been unclear whether the Obama Administration will appeal a trial court's invalidation of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) in Massachusetts. Liberal groups sometimes strategically decline to appeal certain cases when they expect a higher court to rule against them. But the news is not all good for supporters of judicial supremacy. Liberals lament how President Obama has filled only 36 of 134 judgeships that have become vacant during his presidency, despite enjoying a big majority in the Senate to confirm them. While the liberal media blame Republicans for blocking a few nominations, the real cause is Obama's own inability to nominate candidates. http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-judges-blocked-20100801,0,5593662.story There has been no slowdown in judicial supremacy, but the frontier of this struggle is shifting from the U.S. Supreme Court to lower courts. Less is being resolved by the High Court, and more by lower federal courts.