On its last day before adjourning for the summer, the U.S. Supreme Court issued its most contentious decision. It revolved around a simple patent issue: should patent protection extend to the invention of new business methods?
The Court split 5-4 along ideological lines, with Justice Kennedy writing the Court opinion for the conservative bloc and Justice Stevens writing a separate opinion for the liberal bloc. Bilski v. Kappos, 2010 U.S. LEXIS 5521 (June 28, 2010). At stake was how broad the scope of patent law should be in protecting the innovations of small inventors. The five conservative Justices sided with private property (broader patent rights), while the four liberal Justices sought to narrow the scope of patent protections.
All nine Justices agreed on the same outcome for the patent holder in this case, rejecting his particular patent for a method of reducing risk in commodity trading. But the Justices disagreed sharply on the reason why. Justice Stevens, writing for the liberal bloc, insisted that methods of doing business should never be patentable. The final words of his opinion and his nearly 35 years on the Supreme Court were to "strongly disagree with the Court's disposition of this case."
This case had been argued on November 9, 2009, and the eight months required to render its decision was nearly historic in itself. No one expected this low-profile issue to tie the Court in knots for so long.
The exasperation expressed by Justice Stevens at the end of his opinion, along with the Court's unusual delay, suggests that there may have been a behind-the-scenes defection from his group to deprive him of a majority. Further evidence that Stevens' opinion went from majority to minority status is that Justice Kennedy had already been assigned to write another Court opinion that same day of argument, and it seems unlikely that the Chief Justice would have assigned two Court opinions to the same Justice for the same day. Justice Stevens, in contrast, was not assigned any other Court opinions in proximity to this case, which further implies that he was originally supposed to write the Court opinion in this case. The long historical analysis that he included in his opinion reinforces the likelihood that he thought he was writing for the Court, rather than merely for himself and only three other Justices. If so, who defected from Stevens' side to deprive him of a majority? Justice Scalia may have been the one to switch sides, as he has been skeptical toward broad patent rights in the past. There is further evidence that Justice Scalia sympathized with the liberal view; he joined a short concurrence by a member of Stevens' bloc, Justice Breyer.
Justice Stevens and Scalia have long been adversaries. In the flag-burning case of nearly two decades ago, Justice Stevens switched to the conservative side while Justice Scalia switched to the liberal side, such that both still remained opposite each other despite each switching sides.
Like Justice Hugo Black of the Warren Court, Justice Stevens was consistently hostile to religion in public life and to the scope of patent protection, making one wonder if there is one underlying philosophy driving those different positions. Regardless, Justice Stevens was denied a triumphant exit at the end.
Inventor Bilski lost his battle to protect his patent because the Court found his work to be an unpatentable, abstract idea. But small inventors won the war to reverse the lower court's weakening of the patent laws. Thanks to the 5-4 decision and a possible switch in sides by one of the Justices, patents will continue to extend as far and as wide as productivity itself.