For a half-century a goal of liberals has been to eliminate the death penalty in the United States under the "Cruel and Unusual Punishment" clause of the Eighth Amendment. This has been an incremental effort supported by many liberal law firms, which donate pro bono legal services to this cause.
In the early 1970s, this effort persuaded the U.S. Supreme Court to halt executions of criminals and establish more difficult procedural requirements before imposing this punishment. More recently, the Court has flatly prohibited use of the death penalty for any crime committed by someone under age 18 or is deemed to have a low IQ.
Supporters of the death penalty point out that it must be constitutional because it was widely accepted and used when the Constitution was adopted, and implemented ever since both by states and by the U.S. government. The man convicted of kidnapping and killing the Lindbergh baby was executed, and so were individuals convicted of treason. The Bible and the Constitution expressly support the death penalty.
As retribution, the death penalty brings closure for society, and particularly for family members of victims, after a highly disturbing crime. Capital punishment prevents a lingering sense that the criminal "got away with something," and it prevents him from killing again inside or outside of prison. Criminals often plead guilty to avoid facing the death penalty, and this facilitates justice. With DNA and forensic science, mistaken convictions in capital cases have become nearly impossible.
The latest ruling by the Supreme Court on October 26, 2010 in favor of the death penalty was only 5 to 4: Brewer v. Landrigan. This suggests the Court may be only one vote away from striking down numerous laws of the United States and the vast majority of States.
In this case a convicted killer had escaped from prison and then strangled someone to death before he could be captured. Yet a judge stayed his execution based on whether the drug being administered to kill him had been proven to ensure a painless death. The Ninth Circuit agreed and blocked imposition of the death penalty against this twice-convicted killer.
The argument seems absurd on its face, given that the highly painful electric chair was legally used for executions for over a century. But the implausibility of the argument only illustrates the growing judicial hostility to the death penalty, as both the trial and appellate courts blocked the punishment on this basis. The U.S. Supreme Court, by a margin of only one vote, then reversed the judicial blocks and the killer was executed.
Some hardened criminals undergo a religious conversion and publicly repent only after they are sentenced to die. Liberals dislike this, but it is judicial supremacy to declare it unconstitutional. If one conservative Supreme Court Justice is replaced by another liberal, the death penalty may be declared unconstitutional.