It has been a decade since the U.S. Supreme Court invalidated federal laws for unconstitutionally intruding into State authority. In 2000, the Court struck down a provision of the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) that created a private cause of action under federal law, because this issue was traditionally handled by State law. United States v. Morrison. In 1995, in United States v. Lopez, the Court struck down a federal law prohibiting guns near schools on a similar basis.
The issue of how far Congress can go in intruding into local matters has been a hotly contested issue ever since. In 2010, objections on this basis were raised against ObamaCare, whereby the federal government grabs power away from the states and individuals with respect to health insurance and medical care. The Tenth Amendment expressly reserves to the states and the people powers not granted to the federal government.
An unusual dispute was accepted on October 12 for review by the Supreme Court, and the mainstream media have not recognized its significance. The case concerns how Carol Bond used dangerous chemicals to try to inflict harm on her husband’s paramour, who suffered a minor thumb burn as a result. A federal prosecutor insisted on punishing the wife, Mrs. Bond, under a foreign treaty governing chemicals, and for this infraction she received six years in jail. The Supreme Court may address whether the federal government has the power to prosecute this domestic conflict despite being traditionally handled by state rather than federal law.
Court will specifically consider whether the wife, Mrs. Bond, has legal standing to invoke the protection of the Tenth Amendment against prosecution by the federal government. In Carol Bond v. United States, Mrs. Bond argues that the application of a federal law to her violates her rights under the Tenth Amendment. If she prevails, then citizens nationwide could challenge other federal laws by directly asserting their rights under the Tenth Amendment.
The Obama Administration opposes this by arguing that a state must assert the same right under the Tenth Amendment in order for the citizen to be able to assert it as well. In the case of Mrs. Bond, her state (Pennsylvania) did not object to the application of federal law against her even though that law encroached on its traditional power.
The federal law applied against Ms. Bond was 18 U.S.C. § 229(a)(1), which implements a treaty entitled "Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on Their Destruction." It was an arms control agreement never intended to justify prosecution for the misuse of chemicals in the domestic dispute at issue in Ms. Bond’s case. She admitted using chemicals to try to harm her husband’s paramour, but her prosecution under a foreign arms control treaty rather than state law led to a far longer prison sentence.
The Third Circuit allowed the application of federal law to Mrs. Bond, but the Supreme Court’s granting of cert. sets the stage for a possible affirmance or even strengthening of the limits on federal power as set forth in Morrison and Lopez.