Court Monitor • Feb 12, 2011

Crosses Knocked Down by Courts

Text Reader

Two more decisions against the Cross have been rendered by federal appellate courts, the first by the Tenth Circuit (which presides over Utah and Colorado and several neighboring states), and the second by the large Ninth Circuit, which presides over most western and southwestern states. In the first case, a unanimous three-judge panel of the Tenth Circuit ordered the Utah police to take down 12-foot high crosses planted along the highways to honor fallen policemen. Between 1998 and 2003, the Utah Highway Patrol Association erected 13 of these memorials bearing the insignia of the Utah Highway Patrol, using only private funding. The State of Utah owned land on which some of the memorials are located, while Boy Scout troops and local businesses helped the police association in providing funds and maintaining the memorial crosses. Am. Atheists, Inc. v. Duncan, 616 F.3d 1145, 1151 (10th Cir. 2010). The court ruled in favor of the plaintiff American Atheists Inc., based on the First Amendment's prohibition against the establishment of religion. The court ordered that the insignias on the crosses must be removed, and the crosses that are on State land must be uprooted (unless the court decision is reversed on appeal). Then, by a narrow 5-4 margin, all the active judges of the Tenth Circuit declined to reconsider the panel’s ruling. Utah may petition the U.S. Supreme Court to review and reverse the decision. A thousand miles away, the Ninth Circuit was considering whether the 43-foot high Mount Soledad Cross, a large concrete cross raised in Southern California in memory of Korean War veterans, was likewise unconstitutional. The Ninth Circuit held that this famous cross also violates the establishment clause of the First Amendment. Trunk v. City of San Diego, 2011 U.S. App. LEXIS 53 (9th Cir. Jan. 4, 2011). Beginning in 1913, three different crosses have stood on Mount Soledad. The first two were built by groups of private individuals. Even before the creation of the current cross, Mount Soledad was used as a veterans’ memorial park; it was first used for this purpose in 1914. The Mount Soledad Memorial as it exists today was founded in 1952 by the American Legion, not by government. Since the legal controversy over this cross began, the people in two local city elections voted to support both the memorial and the cross. The monument, more than anything else, is a part of the community’s history, and a memorial symbolizing the sacrifices made by our predominantly Christian veterans. This lawsuit against the Soledad cross began in 1989 – over two decades ago. Those who oppose the cross have put forth largely nonsensical legal arguments to claim that the cross on Mount Soledad is somehow unconstitutional, while other crosses which commonly appear in war memorials are not. Little controversy has ever been associated with the crosses at Arlington National Cemetery. Logically, the Arlington crosses would be unconstitutional if the Ninth Circuit decision declaring the Soledad cross to be unconstitutional is upheld. A petition for review by the U.S. Supreme Court is expected. Efforts continue to eradicate the enduring symbol of Christianity from the public square. This may be what atheists want, but it is not what the First Amendment requires.