The new year of 2012 brought with it new regulations by the Obama Administration to limit greenhouse gases resulting from energy production, but Texas is saying "no thanks." It will not give up its economic and energy freedom without a fight.
But Texas lost a skirmish on January 12, when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia lifted a stay (suspension) of the regulations that it had issued back in December. Texas v. EPA, No. 10-1425. The spokesperson for Greg Abbott, the Attorney General for Texas, promised that this momentary setback would not discourage his State from continuing to challenge the overbearing regulations, and there are also additional pending lawsuits.
The EPA seeks to require major producers of greenhouse gases (oil and coal refineries, concrete producers, etc.) to obtain costly permits. The new regulations will greatly restrict or even ban certain chemicals and gases that are currently being released in large amounts. Also, new plants built by these greenhouse gas producers will first need permits and must be built with the "best available control technology" to curb emissions. As an attorney for the liberal-leaning Natural Resources Defense Council declared, the regulations will put "reasonable limits on all of their [greenhouse gas producers'] dangerous pollutants." How "reasonable"? One of these "dangerous pollutants," is merely carbon dioxide, which humans exhale with every breathe!
Texas is the United States’ foremost energy producer, and her major industries produce abundant greenhouse gases. In the absence of viable, efficient alternatives for energy, this regulation of greenhouse gases amounts to energy rationing.
Not only are the regulations themselves unjustified, but so are the means by which the EPA is imposing them. It is "tailoring" the decades-old Clean Air Act to regulate greenhouse gases as well as true toxic pollutants. In so doing, the EPA is legislating rather than regulating, and a regulatory agency is without power to legislate. The EPA goes further and "tailors" the Act so that its new regulations will apply only to certain, major sources of greenhouse gases – not, as the Act would require, to many lesser sources. In essence, the unelected EPA bureaucracy is rewriting an act of Congress.
Only about three percent of all greenhouse gases emitted are man-made. In the face of recent record low temperatures and snowfalls (just a few years ago global warming alarmists were calling snow a "thing of the past"), the whole claim of man-made global warming is more far-fetched than ever.
Greenhouse gas regulation in Texas could cripple energy production there, and at the very least cause much wasted time and money. Given that the whole reason for the regulations is doubtful, the EPA should step back and reevaluate whether or not its regulations – and the questionable legal maneuvers being used to justify them – are really necessary.
The surprise here is not that Texas is standing up to the EPA, but that Texas is the only State to have done so.