Court Monitor • Mar 18, 2011

Free Speech Upheld in Arizona

Text Reader

Amid much publicity about the Tucson Massacre, the media left unnoticed a ruling by the Arizona Supreme Court that vitriolic comments against a public school teacher constituted protected free speech. The court, in a unanimous verdict, said that a student’s profanity-laced tirade may be prosecuted for its disruptive nature, but the speech itself was fully protected by the First Amendment. In re Nickolas S., 2011 Ariz. LEXIS 1 (Ariz. Jan. 10, 2011). The court released its decision on Monday, January 10, 2011, the first working day after the widely publicized shooting rampage in Tucson that left 6 dead, including federal officials, and the congresswoman herself badly injured. Some in the media immediately and wrongly tried to blame Sarah Palin and conservatives for somehow inciting the violence. Meanwhile, this remarkable decision by the Arizona Supreme Court decision sparked no discussion by the mainstream media. The belligerent student, identified only as "Nickolas S.", had been found to be delinquent for violating Arizona Revised Statutes section 15-507. This statute, which was enacted as a territorial law even before Arizona became the 48th state in 1912, criminalizes conduct by "a person who knowingly abuses a teacher or other school employee on school grounds or while the teacher or employee is engaged in the performance of his duties." This law predates the 20th century expansion of free speech in the United States. Nickolas S. engaged in disruptive, intimidating, offensive and profanity-laden remarks to his teacher, a woman, in a classroom setting. There seemed little doubt that the student could be disciplined for his behavior, but the Arizona Supreme Court declined to allow him to be punished solely for his speech under this statute. The student had not engaged in physical abuse, and the court observed that purely verbal abuse is typically constitutionally protected unless the words rise to the high level of "fighting words." "If 'abuse' includes contemptuous, coarse, or insulting words, the statute would extend to a broad range of protected speech directed at school employees while on school grounds or engaged in their duties," the court noted. It then explained that speech may only be prohibited as "fighting words" if "it is likely that the addressee would react violently." Because the teacher was not likely to react violently by physically beating the student, his offensive profanity did not constitute "fighting words" and must be protected free speech. "Arizona teachers exemplify a higher level of professionalism, as the conduct of the teacher involved here reflected. Nickolas's conduct, although reprehensible, is properly punished through school discipline or possibly prosecution under other statutes rather than by characterizing it as fighting words likely to provoke a violent reaction by his teacher," the court held. If the student had directed his comments at a fellow student, who would have been more likely to react violently, then his words could have qualified as "fighting words" and thereby lost his First Amendment protection. The court reversed adjudication of the student's delinquency, but he could have been prosecuted under other statutes that did not rely entirely on the content of his speech.