Court Monitor • Apr 7, 2011

Court Ends 'Federal Defendant' Rule

Text Reader

For decades, the "federal defendant" rule has categorically prohibited groups from intervening in lawsuits to protect recreational use of federal property against environmentalist demands that such use be limited. Such intervention becomes necessary when liberal Administrations do not stand up against the environmentalists. Environmental groups sued to object to allowing access to recreational motorized vehicles on federal land in Idaho, and several groups -- Magic Valley Trail Machine Association, Idaho Recreation Council, and Blue Ribbon Coalition, Inc. -- sought to intervene on the side of the federal government to defend allowing more recreational use of federal land. Their motion to intervene was initially denied under application of the "federal defendant" rule, which has long prevented private groups, state government, and local municipalities from intervening as a matter of right on the merits of claims brought out West under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 ("NEPA"), 42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq. In this case, the Forest Service had adopted a travel plan that designated 1,196 miles of roads and trails for use by motorized vehicles in Idaho's Sawtooth National Forest. Environmental groups sued to block this increased access. Specifically, the Wilderness Society and Prairie Falcon Audubon insisted that the Forest Service had violated NEPA by not preparing an Environmental Impact Statement, by failing to fully consider alternatives, and by erring in other ways. One might wonder what value there is to having environmental protection if no one is able to access it. In the vast Northwest, it is impractical for many to access much of the region without transportation. The Obama Administration was the defendant in this lawsuit, but probably in name only. Obama will be seeking the support of environmental groups and their allies for his reelection bid in 2012, and his vigorous defense against this pro-environmentalist lawsuit could hardly be expected. So it was no surprise when groups favoring greater access to federal lands felt compelled to intervene in order to make sure that their interests were fully represented. The federal district court, relying on the "federal defendant" rule, denied intervention by these recreational groups, and an appeal followed. The U.S. Court of Appeals Ninth Circuit, typically the most liberal and most-reversed Circuit in the nation, then rejected the "federal defendant" rule and allowed the recreational groups to intervene on the side of the federal government, in order to vigorously defend against the lawsuit. "We now abandon the ‘federal defendant’ rule. When considering motions to intervene of right … the operative inquiry should be whether the ‘interest is protectable under some law’ and whether ‘there is a relationship between the legally protected interest and the claims at issue.’ A putative intervenor will generally demonstrate a sufficient interest for intervention of right in a NEPA action, as in all cases, if ‘it will suffer a practical impairment of its interests as a result of the pending litigation.’" Wilderness Soc'y v. United States Forest Serv., 2011 U.S. App. LEXIS 734 (9th Cir. Jan. 14, 2011) As a result, environmental groups seeking judicial activism will now face new opponents: recreational groups that intervene on the side of greater access to federal land.