The biggest news of early 2011 was how Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker courageously stood up to the government workers' unions, and signed a law terminating part of their collective bargaining. Walker did not back down despite weeks of intense protests at the Wisconsin Capitol, and even "fleebagging" by liberal legislators who fled to Illinois in order to delay and impede a vote in their Wisconsin legislature.
The mainstream media lined up against Walker and the Republicans, but that did not alter their strong stance against excessive union power by government workers. Public school teachers even caused the cancellation of school days to join in the protests.
Government workers have the political process to safeguard against poor working conditions or inadequate pay. None of the justifications for unionization in the private sector exists with respect to employees of the government itself.
Ohio and New Hampshire are also seriously considering curbing the power of their public sector unions in order to end runaway expenses. Ohio's law is considered to be even tougher than Wisconsin's, despite attracting less media attention. But unionized government workers, who are twice as numerous in Ohio as Wisconsin, think they can overturn such a law with a referendum.
Back in Wisconsin, opponents of the legislation ran into court to block its implementation. Immediately -- and predictably -- a court issued an injunction against implementing the law.
Wisconsin officials then published the new law on the internet anyway, and declared that the court ruling was not effective in preventing that publication or blocking its implementation. A standoff proceeded for several days, with the court insisting that implementation would be in defiance of its order. Soon the officials backed down, and the law is on hold indefinitely. Meanwhile, liberals made the law an issue in the reelection of a conservative Justice to the Wisconsin Supreme Court, pouring big money into the race to defeat him.
Governor Scott Walker and his allies evidently never considered the likelihood of judicial supremacy tossing their months of hard work and personal sacrifice out the window. The Wisconsin state court, with a few strokes of the pen, overrode both houses of the Wisconsin legislature and the Governor, who had been duly elected by the people.
The solution to such judicial supremacy is to withdraw jurisdiction from the courts. This has been done by Congress, by both Democrats and Republicans, to prevent this type of scenario that has frustrated the will of the people in Wisconsin. Examples include the withdrawal of jurisdiction over challenges to reimbursement schedules for Medicare, lawsuits against gun manufacturers, and environmentalist objections to the clearing of underbrush in South Dakota (enacted when its liberal Senator Tom Daschle was the Majority Leader).
Most Wisconsin courts -- like federal courts -- are dependent on the legislature for the scope of their jurisdiction. See Wisconsin Constitution, Article VII. The Wisconsin Supreme Court has stated repeatedly: "No litigant has a vested right in a particular remedy, so he can have none in rules of procedure which relate to the remedy." Elm Park Iowa, Inc. v. Denniston, 91 Wis. 2d 227 (Wis. 1979). That decision also made clear that no litigant has a right to a particular court or venue. Scott Walker's legislation should not allow challengers to pick any venue they like.