In the late 1900s, the U.S. Supreme Court accepted and decided numerous cases arising under the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. These cases have concerned the display of the Ten Commandments, student religious clubs at public school, Christmas displays on public property, and so on.
The Court was split 5-4 on many of these issues, with Justice Sandra Day O'Connor typically voting against religion on public property. But Justice Sam Alito replaced Justice O'Connor in early 2006, giving a solid five votes (and sometimes six) in favor of allowing religious displays on public property. It seemed likely that the Court would begin holding in favor of religious displays and overturning precedents to the contrary.
But during the subsequent 6.5 years, this has not happened. Instead, the Court has repeatedly avoided ("denied cert.") important Establishment Clause cases brought before it.
For example, the predictably liberal Ninth Circuit ruled against the Cross on Mount Soledad in California, which is part of a veterans' memorial on federal land. It seemed almost certain that the Supreme Court would "grant cert." and hear this much publicized controversy, which has been ongoing for 23 years and cries out for a definitive resolution. But the Court ducked the issue and denied cert.
In two other cases, both involving privately erected roadside crosses for Utah Highway Patrol officers, the Tenth Circuit held that the crosses were an improper "government's endorsement" of Christianity. Both cases were appealed to the Supreme Court, but the Court "denied cert." on both.
There have been surprising denials of cert. in additional Establishment Clause cases. In Nampa Classical Academy v. Goesling, the Ninth Circuit banned charter schools from using religious texts in the classroom -- for the teaching of secular subjects! The Supreme Court declined to consider it. In another case, the Ninth Circuit affirmed a lower ruling forcing a teacher to remove patriotic posters that mentioned God from his classroom. The Supreme Court also refused to take that case.
Justice Scalia has not written a judicial opinion in defense of a religious display or textbook in more than seven years. Other conservative jurists have likewise kept mostly silent on this topic.
Why? Even when the Court denies cert., there is still an opportunity for a Justice to express disagreement with what the lower court did in censoring religion.
One theory is that the Supreme Court is waiting for the right case, but with multiple passing opportunities to correct lower court rulings that are intolerant of religion, it is difficult to imagine for what case the Court would be waiting. If Crosses, textbooks, and posters in high-profile cases are not suitable for High Court review, then it is doubtful anything else would be.
A more plausible explanation is that the Supreme Court has become content and complacent, seeking to avoid internally divisive issues. The media praise how collegial the current Justices have become, which implies that liberals expect to do better if there is collegiality. For much of the 20th century, in contrast, the Supreme Court was bitterly divided internally, but often productive.
This media-encouraged collegiality seems to be a one-way street for liberal misuse of the Establishment Clause, with censorship of religion by lower courts continuing to prevail despite the silent views of a majority of the Supreme Court.