Court Monitor • Oct 28, 2012

Supreme Court Ties Arizona's Hands on Immigration Issue

Text Reader

Arizona would be the new Ellis Island, if it were not for the painful fact that the migrations over Arizona's borders are almost entirely illegal. Indeed, almost half of the illegal immigration into the entire United States occurs along Arizona's border. Arizona is burdened with hundreds of millions of dollars in annual costs due to this massive influx, and has unsuccessfully asked the federal government for help. In 2010, Arizona passed SB 1070 to combat the influx of illegal aliens into the State. The Obama Administration filed suit to enjoin the law, particularly two provisions that create new misdemeanors under state law, and two additional provisions expanding the authority of law enforcement to arrest and investigate aliens. SB 1070 made it a misdemeanor for anyone to fail to comply with alien registration requirements of the federal government, and also made it a misdemeanor for an illegal alien to seek or perform work in the State. A misdemeanor is considered to be a minor crime; traffic tickets are examples of misdemeanors. Two provisions for arresting suspected aliens caused much of the public controversy concerning this new law. Section 6 of the law authorized police to arrest anyone, without a warrant, if the officer "has probable cause to believe [that the suspect] . . . has committed any public offense that makes the person removable from the United States." Section 2(B) requires the police in some circumstances to check the immigration status of a suspect who has been stopped, detained or arrested. The Obama Administration sued, and the district court in Arizona enjoined all four of the above provisions, thereby preventing them from going into effect. The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed, and the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case. With a 5-3 conservative majority on the Court for this case (Obama-appointed Justice Elena Kagan was compelled to recuse herself from the case due to her involvement in its early stages), the expectations were high for a reinstatement of the Arizona law. But the Court struck down three of the four key provisions, thereby tying the hands of Arizona in defending itself against illegal aliens. Arizona v. United States, 132 S. Ct. 2492 (June 25, 2012). It allowed only Section 2(B) to remain enforceable, and even then it left open the possibility for that provision to be invalidated by a federal court in the future. "It was improper, however, to enjoin § 2(B) before the state courts had an opportunity to construe it and without some showing that enforcement of the provision in fact conflicts with federal immigration law and its objectives," the Court ruled. Section 2(B) as written conflicts with Obama Administration policy friendly to illegal migration, but does not conflict with laws passed by Congress. The Court's rationale for invalidating most of the key parts of the law was that the federal government, not the states, regulates immigration. In legalese, this means that federal courts can invalidate state laws for being "preempted" by the (ineffective) federal regulation on this topic. This regrettably ties the hands of municipalities, such as Arizona, that try to combat the expenses, crime and other problems that massive illegal migration causes.