Court Monitor • Nov 24, 2012

Eighth Circuit Rules Against Planned Parenthood

Text Reader

On July 24, an en banc sitting of the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit rendered a 7-4 judgment against Planned Parenthood, thereby reinstating a South Dakota law requiring abortion providers to disclose to patients that there is a higher incidence of suicide among women who have had abortions. Planned Parenthood v. Rounds, Nos. 09-3231/3233/3362 (8th Cir. 2012). This was the culmination of 7 years of litigation dating back to June 2005. An en banc sitting of a federal appellate court is a rare event in which all the active judges, totaling 11 for the Eighth Circuit, participate in the consideration and decision of an issue. Only a tiny percentage of petitions for rehearing en banc are typically granted. This mandatory disclosure of a higher suicide rate was so controversial within the Eighth Circuit that it resulted in two en banc sittings during the same litigation, which is virtually unheard of. It would be comparable to the U.S. Supreme Court hearing and deciding the same case twice, which is extremely rare but has likewise occurred in the context of the divisive abortion issue. The South Dakota law is as simple as it is controversial. It requires, as part of informed consent, that abortion providers give a written disclosure about the higher suicide rate among women who have an abortion, so that women considering abortion can be aware of that potential side effect. Abortion providers were not required to say that abortion causes an increased risk of suicide, but merely that there is a correlation between abortion and subsequent suicide. As held earlier this year by the Fifth Circuit and quoted favorably by the Eighth Circuit, "[t]he point of informed consent laws is to allow the patient to evaluate her condition and render her best decision under difficult circumstances. Denying her up-to-date medical information is more of an abuse to her ability to decide than providing the information." Texas Medical Providers Performing Abortion Services v. Lakey, 667 F.3d 570, 579 (5th Cir. 2012). Back in 2005, a district court in South Dakota blocked enforcement of this requirement of the suicide advisory. It is commonplace for Planned Parenthood to obtain an injunction against any state law that might interfere with its business, and it became necessary to argue the issues several times on appeal before obtaining a verdict upholding the statutory provision. Even on appeal, a 2-1 panel ruled in 2011 that the mandatory suicide advisory was unconstitutional. Thanks to the tireless efforts of pro-life attorney Harold Cassidy, the Eighth Circuit granted his petition to go "en banc" to reconsider the unfavorable panel decision, and Judge Raymond Gruender (who was in dissent on the panel) wrote the final opinion for the en banc court. He had a narrow majority with which to work: his opinion prevailed by 5-4 as two additional judges, James Loken and Steven Colloton, wrote weaker opinions expressing reservations but concurring in the judgment. It seems unlikely that Planned Parenthood will appeal this ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court, and thereby risk a national precedent against them on this issue. Accordingly, Arkansas, the Dakotas, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, and Nebraska may all soon require a disclosure about suicide prior to an abortion.