Court Monitor • Dec 2, 2012

ObamaCare, the Tax

Text Reader

The most-awaited Supreme Court decision in years was handed down shortly after 10 a.m. on June 28, 2012. National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius, 183 L. Ed. 2d 450 (2012). To the disappointment of many, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of ObamaCare on the basis that it is a tax, while finding it could not be sustained under the Commerce Clause. Five of the Justices -- a majority -- held that ObamaCare, whose official name is the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, went beyond federal power under the Commerce Clause and could not be upheld under that provision of the Constitution. But, alas, the Court found another way to sustain ObamaCare, by resorting to what the Democrats had repeatedly denied before, during and after its passage: that it is a tax. This tax consists of the penalty that Americans will pay as part of their annual tax filing if they have not purchased a government-approved health insurance plan. The amount of that tax depends on a variety of factors, and could total thousands of dollars each for many working Americans. Straining to uphold ObamaCare, the Court bypassed the plain words of the law itself, the statements of the legislators who voted for it, the focus of extensive oral arguments before the Court in late March, and the application of the Tax Anti-Injunction Act, which removes jurisdiction from federal courts over lawsuits seeking to block the collection of taxes. This ruling was activist in the unexpected way that it reached to uphold the legislation, which passed without a single Republican vote in 2010. The result is dreadful for American businesses, violating two fundamental rules about recessions: never raise taxes during a recession, and don't create economic uncertainty. The lingering economic uncertainty is causing employers to delay their planning, with only 40 percent of businesses in a survey saying they would begin preparing for ObamaCare's plethora of provisions before the presidential election. http://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2012/07/10/254973.htm One provision requires employees working 30 or more hours weekly to be eligible for employer provided coverage. Since a part-time worker is just as expensive to insure as a full-time worker -- each costing about $10,000 -- businesses may react by laying off or reducing hours for workers, which could cause additional problems for the economy. Numerous employees may lose their insurance as a result of ObamaCare. A survey by the consulting firm McKinsey & Company (http://blog.heritage.org/2011/06/08/huge-number-of-businesses-to-drop-health-insurance-thanks-to-Obamacare/) suggests that between 30 and 50 percent of private sector employers may drop or consider dropping coverage. The Congressional Budget Office published a considerably lower number, but acknowledged that "there is clearly a tremendous amount of uncertainty about how employers and employees will respond" to the law. http://www.cbo.gov/publication/43082