A 12-year-old criticized a public school employee on a private area of her Facebook wall, but somehow school officials learned about it. The school principal called the youngster to his office and purportedly told her that her private posting somehow constituted impermissible bullying. The principal ordered the student to apologize to the school employee, who was a hall monitor, and gave the student a detention. The school then allegedly put entries in her disciplinary records, including a comment that she was "rude/discourteous."
When the student later vented her frustration with a second posting on her Facebook wall, asking who had turned her in, the school disciplined her again. The school allegedly suspended her for one day from school and prohibited her from attending a class ski trip.
All this discipline for comments merely made by a student outside of school hours and off school grounds? Don't public schools have better things to do than to police what students say on their own time?
The girl and her mother sued the public school, the principal, and other government officials. In addition to the above allegations, they also asserted that the girl was interrogated by a deputy sheriff assigned to the school, in the presence of school officials, about comments possibly of a sexual nature that the student supposedly made to a male classmate. The school officials demanded that the girl provide her passwords to her Facebook and email accounts so that they could search what she had written. The school officials then allegedly logged into the student's Facebook account and perused it.
When sued, the school moved to dismiss the case. But the court rejected the school's motion and has sided, for now, with the girl and her parent. R.S. and S.S. v. Minnewaska Area School District No. 2149, Civ. No. 12-588 (MJD/LIB) (D. Minn. Sept. 6, 2012).
The Court held that out-of-school statements by students "are protected under the First Amendment and not punishable by school authorities unless they are true threats or are reasonably calculated to reach the school environment and are so egregious as to pose a serious safety risk or other substantial disruption in that environment." Even if the girl's criticism of a school official was reasonably calculated to reach a school audience, "that possible fact is not sufficient to justify her punishment."
This decision cited approvingly two en banc decisions by the Third Circuit in 2011, in which that appellate court upheld the right of free speech by students to make offensive remarks about school officials on the internet: Layshock ex rel. Layshock v. Hermitage School District, 650 F.3d 205 (3d Cir. 2011) (en banc) and J.S. ex rel. Snyder v. Blue Mountain School Distict, 650 F.3d 915 (3d Cir. 2011) (en banc).
While it is not yet clear if anything good will come of these free speech precedents, this does open the possibility of public accountability as students can now freely criticize liberal propaganda in public schools.