In several key battleground states for the presidential election this year, early voting began before the first presidential debate. More than 50% of voters cast their ballots prior to Election Day in some battleground states in 2008, and that percentage is expected to grow even larger in 2012.
In 2008, many Floridians cast their ballots prior to Election Day, and Obama won it by a surprisingly large margin. This year, statistical analysis may even predict before Election Day which presidential candidate wins Florida, and announce to Americans nationwide that the election is over before Election Day.
How many will then bother to cast a moot vote on Election Day? That would be like watching a football game played last year, or going to a major league baseball game where an umpire selects a winner before nine innings are played. The interest in such contests would be virtually nil.
Early voting was sold to the American people by claiming that the convenience would increase voter turnout. But this was a false promise. Early voting may be slightly more convenient than voting on Election Day, but it is even more convenient not to vote at all, which is what is occurring in droves as Election Day loses its historic meaning. In some states, Election Day was revered like other holidays, and some businesses even let workers off for the day so they could vote. But early voting has undermined the integrity and respect for voting, and the potential for fraud or intimidation is vast. Carter may have defeated Reagan in 1980 if there had been as much early voting as there is today, because Reagan benefited from a late shift in voters to his side. Today, most voters cannot shift to anyone because they already cast their ballots early.
Critics of how big money is taking over politics note that early voting is exacerbating this problem. Early voting in the Florida Republican primary requires candidates to spend massive amounts of money over an extended period of time, which is something most grassroots candidates cannot do. In contrast, victories by conservative Senate candidates in primaries in Nebraska and Missouri were possible because early voting is disfavored in those states.
But courts and the Obama Administration have interfered with sensible attempts by states, including Florida and Ohio, to trim back excessive early voting. The Obama Administration invoked its power under the Voting Rights Act to prevent several counties in Florida from reducing its early voting hours. Democrats are urging courts to require states to have expansive early voting, perhaps because Democrats have found ways to exploit early voting for their own advantage.
Democracy depends on an open-minded electorate. Encouraging people to close their minds and cast an irrevocable ballot early is as harmful as it would be to allow jurors to vote and go home before they hear all the evidence in a trial, which is not and should not be allowed.